Best Western (Timely, 1949) #58 - 59

id: 999483 not VIP Open in MaM

By Timely Comics

Series: Best Western #58-59

Language: English

Category: Comic Book / Graphic Novel - Comics/Graphic Novels Violence

Categories: Superheroes

Size: 84 MiB cbz Files: 6

Uploader: TedBronson

Uploaded At: 2024-01-22 04:47:33

western, cowboys, black.rider, kid.colt, marvel, golden.age, 1949

Description

Best Western was a Western themed comic published by Timely Comics in 1949. Only two issues were published.

The numbering for this series started at #58, which does not align with any other series at the time. However Dr. Michael Vassallo in his blog (timely-atlas-comics.blogspot.com) posits the following reason:

But where did this numbering come from? #58? #59?

The first thought that jumped into my head was that perhaps these were the 58th and 59th issues in the long Best Western publishing run. A quick count of all the pulp issues proves this not so. There had only been 36 previous pulp issues in this title so if anything, these two comic book issues should have been #37 and #38, respectively.

No, there had to be a different explanation, but nothing in the pulps seemed to work out.

...

Absolutely "nothing" appears to explain Best Western #59. The closest numerical and distance match is the title Terrytoons, which ends its Timely run at #59 (Aug/47) and was published by the sub-company Timely Comics, Inc., nearly two whole years before Best Western #58 appears. It's the closest numerical match, meaning that it's remotely possible Best Western "spun off" the near-last issue of Terrytoons, #57 (June/47). Maybe it was a clerical error not unlike Love Tales #59. Perhaps the Best Western comic book should have been #60 and #61, cleanly following Terrytoons' numbering.

So is this cover above the answer to where Best Western #58 derived? I'm extremely doubtful about the whole thing, but it's the only thing I can come up with. I just don't have the answer and perhaps this one will never be solved.

ADDENDA:

Right after this post was put to bed, my pal Jim Vadeboncoeur, Jr. made a startling revelation that may have solved this mystery! In fact, it's so obvious I cannot believe I didn't consider this as it was right under my nose all along! Right after the last pulp Best Western issue, Vol 5, #7, the first comic book issue is #58. You see it? There is no Vol 5, #8 but Goodman squeezes it to #58! And then, what would have been Vol 5, #9 becomes #59! Can we know for sure? No, but it is absolutely the best possible answer. Martin Goodman loved to frequently launch new titles with "high" numbers, making them look like newsstand veterans as well as fooling the post office looking to collect on the registration of new titles. Usually the high numbers carried on from earlier cancelled comic titles, but as I've shown, once in a while Goodman used cross-format methods. Thanks, Jim!


The short-lived Best Western contained western stories featuring several of Timely's other western characters, including Black Rider, Two-Gun Kid, and Kid Colt.

Other related Comics:

  • All Western Winners (1948-1949)
  • Annie Oakley (1948-1956)
  • Apache Kid (1950-1956)
  • Best Western (1949)
  • Black Rider (1950-1955)
  • Blaze Carson (1948-1949)
  • Cowgirl Romances (1950)
  • The Gunhawk (1950-1951)
  • Gunsmoke Western (1955-1963)
  • Kid Colt (1948-1979,2009)
  • Reno Browne (1950)
  • Rex Hart (1949-1950)
  • Romances of the West (1949-1950)
  • Tex Morgan (1948-1950)
  • Tex Taylor (1948-1950)
  • True Western (1949-1950)
  • Two Gun Western Vol 1 (1950-1952)
  • Two-Gun Kid (1948-1977)
  • Western Gunfighters (1956-1957)
  • Western Outlaws and Sheriffs (1949-1952)
  • Western Tales of Black Rider (1955)
  • Western Winners (1949)
  • Whip Wilson (1950)
  • Wild West (1948)
  • Wild Western (1948-1957)
    Timeline for this comic chain:

    Best Western #58 - 59 (1949) -> Western Outlaws and Sheriffs #60 - 69 (1949-1951) -> Western Outlaws and Sheriffs (Atlas) #70 - 73 (1951-1952)

    I have created separate torrents for each title in the chain above. All issues are included and are fully complete (unless otherwise noted below), though quality does vary. I was able to source many of these scans, and rip them from the web, which only had covers included in the Complete Marvel Chronology sets. I used them as a starting point, by including those comics which are available first, then seeking to fill the remaining gaps. I hope to provide a complete set of all Marvel Golden Age comics from the 1930's to 1960, and then continue on with the Silver Age, and on to the Modern era. It's a huge undertaking but I tend to enjoy a challenge <img border=" title=":-)" />

    Please note that these comics were written in the 40s and 50s and the terms used, positions held, and/or actions taken by the characters, editors, or advertisers in no way reflect the views of the uploader!


    NOTE: The following issues are incomplete or missing:
    All issues complete!


    If you can provide a more complete scan for any of these comics, please let me know so I can update the collection.

    Please check out the Marvel Comics Collection Spreadsheet below to find the torrents for other series and see what comics are coming up soon!

    Marvel Comics Collection Spreadsheet: https://cryptpad.fr/sheet/#/2/sheet/view/P6TGXBRFB2KTbEluVIFYMAcmQe4GZTpCt9Br57NJ73g/

  • Other Torrents