The Turn to Gruesomeness in American Horror Films, 1931-1936
By Jon Towlson
Language: English
Category: Ebook - Art
Categories: Art/Photography
Uploader: Slappy9001
Uploaded At: 2023-09-20 10:59:05
Copyright 2016. Film, General, History, Performing Arts
Description
Is the thirties horror film more akin to graphic modern horror than is often thought?
Critics have traditionally characterized classic horror by its use of shadow and suggestion. Yet the graphic nature of early 1930s films only came to light in the home video/DVD era. Along with gangster movies and "sex pictures," horror films drew audiences during the Great Depression with sensational screen content. Exploiting a loophole in the Hays Code, which made no provision for on-screen "gruesomeness," studios produced remarkably explicit films that were recut when the Code was more rigidly enforced from 1934. This led to a modern misperception that classic horror was intended to be safe and reassuring to audiences.
Taking a fresh look at the genre from 1931 through 1936, this critical study examines "happy ending" horror in relation to industry practices and censorship. Early works like Murders in the Rue Morgue (1932) and The Raven (1935) may be more akin to The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (2003) and Saw (2004) than many critics believe.
'This may well be the book on 'classic horror' to beat this year"- Tim Lucas, VIDEO WATCHDOG
Nominated for BOOK OF THE YEAR (2016) - RONDO HATTON CLASSIC HORROR AWARDS
"One of the best Horror Film books of all time" - BookAuthority
From the Author
"Too Dreadfully Gruesome": In Conversation with author Jon Towlson (Diabolique Magazine, March 2017).
Can you tell me about the genesis of this project? I recall you wrote about the subversive nature of 1930s horror films in issue 17 of Paracinema.
That's right. I wrote that piece about the endings of 30s horror pictures, mainly to argue against the idea that 30s horror is inherently conservative because the endings always restore the status quo. It struck me when I was watching these films that the endings of so many of them, from Frankenstein onwards, were tacked-on by the studio (often after disastrous previews) and just unconvincing. Often the happy endings were there to placate censors. So can thirties horror films be truly defined by this idea that they restore the status quo?
As I began to research further, I started to think to myself, ok, if we need to redefine thirties horror - what is its primary characteristic if not its reassuring ending? And what came up again and again in the censorship notes, the marketing and the studio memos of these films was the word 'gruesomeness'.
Even before films were being termed horror films, they were being called 'gruesome pictures'. And that was how the studios sold these movies in the pre-Code era, as gruesome pictures, like machine guns in gangster pictures or sex in sex pictures from the 30s. When the Production Code Administration started to tighten the Hays Code up in the mid-thirties, it was gruesomeness that they looked at in horror pictures, and eventually they took steps to eradicate it. 1940s horror films were less graphic, and relied more on ghostliness and psychology as a result. But gruesomeness makes the thirties films very edgy, and quite brutal.
Horror cinema was a fledgling genre back in the 30s, indeed, as you say, they weren't even referred to as 'horror' pictures until later in that decade. Was it always obvious to you which films you needed to examine for this project?
What was great was being able to go through all of the Hays Code files to see which films had been censored and why. And what I found was that more or less all of the films that we think of as iconic now, from Dracula (1931) to The Black Cat (1934) all had files on them, and were considered (and sometimes vetted) very carefully by the Hays Code officials in terms of their gruesomeness. And it was possible to trace a trajectory from 1931 to 1936 to see how films like Dracula's Daughter (1936) and The Devil Doll (1936) were affected by the clampdown on gruesomeness as the decade wore on. Then you get lesser known films like Murders in the Zoo (1933) which seems to have been conceived almost as a marketing ploy to push gruesomeness. The opening scene, for example, where the guy has his mouth sewed shut, wasn't even in the original treatment. It was added later after a script conference as a kind of publicity generator, and the film's marketing played on that scene. But, yes, even the more obscure films, like Black Moon (1934) and Night of Terror (1933) had gruesome stuff eliminated by the Hays Office either from the finished film or at the script stage.
What would you say to those people who view 1930s horror films as tame and full of happy endings?
That view has persisted for a number of reasons: a) pre-Code horror films were re-censored after the Production Code was tightened up from 1934 onwards; so if a film was reissued it was often cut for re-issue even if it hadn't been censored before that - and sometimes censored even more than it had been on first release. So for decades, films like Frankenstein , Murder in the Rue Morgue , King Kong and many others were shown in censored versions. It's really only in the DVD age that we have been able to see most of these in their full glory with cuts restored. b) Some influential historians and critics have perpetuated this idea of tameness, often lumping together the thirties and forties films into one classic era. However, as I said, the thirties films were more gruesome, whereas Universal went family-friendly in the 40s with the monster rallies. But we still look upon the two eras, thanks to historians like William K. Everson and Denis Gifford, with a rosy glow of nostalgia. They've become mythologised. Nothing against these historians - they're important writers - but the thirties pictures are not as safe and reassuring as they were made out to be. c) The Monster Kid generation saw these movies mainly on TV in the 50s and 60s, PCA-cut versions, and, again mixed together with 40s horrors, which kind of jumbled both eras up in people's minds. Plus a number of key titles like Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1931) and Murders in the Zoo weren't included in the Shock Theatre showings, and some remained unseen altogether for many years, and this also led to an incomplete picture of the 30s cycle.
Do you think it's fair to say that the efforts of the early censorship boards, to suppress certain content in the emerging horror genre, only served to help make it what it is today?
The 30s horror film was really a continuation of the tradition of Grand Guignol theatre, so graphic modern horror's influences extend way back before even the thirties horror films. The idea that horror has become more graphic and gruesome as time has gone on is true, in relative terms. Sure, special make up effect have become more convincing and to an extent more graphic, but filmmakers were still gouging the eyes out of cats in the 1930s! ( Maniac , 1934). The ideas were still horrible and shocking. But, yes, I think censorship - in terms of what far you could actually show in any given era - has certainly influenced the way violence in all genres has been represented on screen from the thirties onwards, including in horror films. The Production Code was at its strongest in the 1940s and early 1950s, and that coincides with a lack of gruesomeness in the horror films of that period. The introduction of Technicolor, as well, had a big influence on gruesomeness in later years when you consider how Hammer made use of 'Kensington Gore' in the late 50s, and how that led to more graphic content as the Production Code dissolved in the 60s, with Blood Feast (1963) etc.
Can you point to any recent titles in particular that bear the influence of 30s horror cinema?
Any movie where you have someone strapped down and tortured - you only have to look at the sequence of Murders in the Rue Morgue (1931) where Bela Lugosi crucifies a prostitute to see the influence!
About the Author
Jon Towlson is a UK-based journalist and film critic. He has written for the British Film Institute, Senses of Cinema, Digital Filmmaker Magazine, Scream, The Dark Side, Starburst Magazine, Paracinema, Exquisite Terror, Irish Journal of Gothic and Horror Studies, Shadowland Magazine and Bright Lights Film Journal.