The War Between the Generals: Inside the Allied High Command

id: 930268 not VIP Open in MaM

By David Irving

Language: English

Category: Ebook - History

Categories: Historical

Size: 3.7 MiB pdf Files: 1

Uploader: Vinylla

Uploaded At: 2023-05-09 19:35:51

WWII generals, allied forces, Eisenhower, Churchill, Patton, 1981

Description

Inside story of some of the fiercest battles of World War II - those inside the allied command structure.

Excerpts from review:

This is an untold story of the primary American and British leaders who led the great invasion of the France through the end of hostilities in 1945. It is untold because Irving brings out all the frictions between them, which are mostly ignored or inadequately covered in mainstream history books.
The key players are Churchill, Eisenhower, Patton, Bradley, Montgomery, Spaatz, DeGaulle, Tedder, and Leigh-Mallory who get the most attention by Irving. He does touch on the other subordinates of three star and a few division commanders of two star rank as necessary.

One of the great myths Irving dispels is that D-Day was a well-executed invasion. Patton, for example, did not think so. He felt the landing area was too narrow, and would allow the Germans to more easily contain it and defeat it. Irving also well shows that Eisenhower, Bradley, and Montgomery were following a path of containment by the Germans with their slow and careful movement inland. By July 1944, the Germans were starting to move enough reinforcements into the area, and Eisenhower was less confident a war of movement would be possible as the Germans were punishing the Allied formations more and more. He made the comment at this time, he wished his leaders were like Patton, and it was at this time he decided to make 3rd Army operational and let Patton lead it. It was the use of Patton and his different mindset who got movement going. Irving strongly highlights Patton as the best the Allies had, and it was his movements that well showed Bradley and Montgomery and Eisenhower were entirely too hesitant. A great quote by Patton Irving chose was: “One should never penalize a commander for mistakes due to audacity.” In contrast to this, a surprising comment by Montgomery at the start of the Battle of the Bulge, well exemplifies the diffference. He wrote to Churchill concerned that “if the Germans push us out again, (from Europe) we can’t go through Dunkirk this time, they hold that this time.”

Irving also exemplifies the qualities of the German military, and how professionally it conducted itself, despite the misguided Fȕhrer directives to hold ground and not allow it to operationally maneuver (resulting in the loss of masses of troops and material in the Falaise pocket). It was the Germans, who took great pains to care for the French civilian population casualties from the Allied bombing campaign. “The Germans had prepared forty thousand extra hospital beds throughout northern France, with twenty-eight thousand more standing by in Paris and Brussels.”

It is probably these aspects of the war that Irving brings out in his books that his detractors hate. Things that prove the German Wehrmacht were not bad guys, but men of honor who felt a responsibility for the French people as occupiers. Or how Patton “came to admire the Germans, the very people he had been fighting. Everything he saw of Russians, Poles, and Jews aroused loathing in him.” In August 1944 Patton wrote his wife, “The stuff in the papers about fraternization is all wet…writing done by Jews to get revenge…” The Patton papers Irving brings out extensively in his work, and he hides nothing.

Other Torrents