The Scientific Method: A Guide to Finding Useful Knowledge
By Jon Scott Armstrong, Kesten C Green
Language: English
Category: Ebook - Math/Science/Tech
Categories: Science
Uploader: bluebayou
Uploaded At: 2022-11-03 10:02:40
2022 Cambridge University Press | 220 pages | eight essential criteria for the practice of science, checklists to help avoid costly failures in scientific practice
Description
The scientific method delivers prosperity, yet scientific practice has become subject to corrupting influences from within and without the scientific community. This essential reference is intended to help remedy those threats. The authors identify eight essential criteria for the practice of science and provide checklists to help avoid costly failures in scientific practice. Not only for scientists, this book is for all stakeholders of the broad enterprise of science. Science administrators, research funders, journal editors, and policymakers alike will find practical guidance on how they can encourage scientific research that produces useful discoveries. Journalists, commentators, and lawyers can turn to this text for help with assessing the validity and usefulness of scientific claims. The book provides practical guidance and makes important recommendations for reforms in science policy and science administration.
The message of the book is complemented by Nobel Laureate Vernon L. Smith's foreword, and an afterword by Terence Kealey.
DOI:https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009092265
Contents
1 Introduction
1.1 Plan of This Book
1.2 Scientific Method versus Scientist Opinion
1.3 Objective of the Scientific Method
1.4 Objectives of Scientific Practice Subverting Science
1.5 Operational Guidelines for Scientific Practice
2 Defining the Scientific Method
2.1 An Aspirational Definition
2.2 Criteria for Complying with the Scientific Method
3 Checklist for the Scientific Method
3.1 Development of the Compliance With Science Checklist
3.2 Using the Checklist: For What, How, and by Whom
3.3 Not All Checklists Are Useful
3.4 Ensuring That Checklists Are Used
4 Assessing the Quality of Scientific Practice
4.1 How We Reviewed Evidence on Research Practice
4.2 Do Journal Papers Help Readers to Make Better Decisions?
4.3 More Replications of Important Papers Needed
4.4 Are Papers in Scientific Journals Replicable?
4.5 How Much of a Concern Is Cheating?
4.6 How Efficient Is Research?
5 Scientific Practice: Problem of Advocacy
5.1 Unnaturalness of Objectivity
5.2 Confirmation Bias
5.3 How Advocacy Is Practiced
5.4 Prevalence and Acceptance of Advocacy
6 Scientific Practice: Problem of Journal Reviews
6.1 Failure to Find Errors
6.2 Advocacy by Reviewers and Editors
6.3 Unreliable Reviews
6.4 Failure to Improve Papers
6.5 Fooled by Fraudulent Reviews and Bafflegab
6.6 Distracted by Statistical Significance Tests
6.7 Blind to Importance of Authors’ Previous Contributions
6.8 Long Delays in Publication
7 Scientific Practice: Problem of Government Involvement
7.1 Being Useful
7.2 Funding
7.3 Regulation
8 What It Takes To Be a Good Scientist
8.1 General Mental Ability
8.2 Family Propensity
8.3 Early Desire to Do Scientific Research
8.4 Personality
8.5 Motivated by Intrinsic Rewards
8.6 Self-Control
8.7 Skepticism
8.8 Your Decision
8.9 Navigating a Doctoral Program
8.10 Acting as a Scientist in all Relevant Roles
9 How Scientists Can Discover Useful Knowledge
9.1 Identifying Important Problems
9.2 Selecting a Problem
9.3 Designing a Study
9.4 Collecting Data
9.5 Analyzing Data
10 How Scientists Can Disseminate Useful Findings
10.1 Writing a Scientific Paper
10.2 Disseminating Findings
11 How Stakeholders Can Help Science
11.1 Universities
11.2 Scientific Journals
11.3 Governments, Regulators, and Courts
11.4 Media and Interested Groups and Individuals
12 Rescuing Science from Advocacy
12.1 From Where Should Funding Come?
12.2 Advocacy
12.3 Bureaucracy and Irrelevant Incentives
12.4 How Stakeholders Can Contribute