The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy
By John J Mearsheimer, Stephen M Walt
Language: English
Category: Audiobook - General Non-fic
Categories: Politics/Sociology
Uploader: compmast
Uploaded At: 2011-10-06 01:00:19
The powerful presence of the Israel Lobby in US politics...exposed. Controversial indeed!
Description
This book is stunning. The two authors are prominent political scientists with
impeccable credentials, hailing from Harvard and the University of Chicago. They
have boldly gone where many of their academic colleagues would fear to tread.
Although their conclusions about Israel and its negative influence on American
foreign policy will awaken much anxiety, resentment and fury in certain
quarters, Walt and Mearsheimer don't seem to care. Why not? They are scientists.
They appeal to logic, facts and common sense; and let the conclusions fall where
they may. The writing is calm, dispassionate, thorough. The basic argument is
that the extraordinarily high degree of economic, military and diplomatic
support given to Israel by the United States cannot be explained or justified by
the notion that Israel functions as a strategic asset to the U.S., or that
Israel as the "only democracy" amidst a sea of authoritarian neighbors is
deserving of special favor for its "shared interests and values". In fact, the
authors claim, Israel is more a liability than an asset. During the Cold War,
the strategic-value argument had perhaps some plausibility -- but no longer.
What has replaced the Soviet menace, as the enemy which the U.S. supposedly
needs Israel's help to combat, is Islamic terrorism. But the U.S. favor shown to
Israel at the expense of the Palestinians only makes us more not less vulnerable
to terrorism. Furthermore Israel's cruelty towards the Palestinians and its
essential nature as a Jewish but not a truly democratic state in which all
citizens of whatever ethnicity or religion would be given equal rights and
respect, belie the "shared values" argument.
So if neither "shared
values" nor "strategic asset" can explain the overwhelming U.S. support of
Israel, what else is there? The power of the Israel lobby, which has brought
about a situation in which it is impossible for elected officials to question
support for Israel, much less redirect foreign policy in any way contrary to the
perceived self-interest of Israel. This has led the U.S. to make critical
mistakes, such as invading and occupying Iraq. The war on Iraq has proven
disastrous; the authors argue that the U.S. would not have attacked Iraq, were
it not for the influence of the Israel lobby.
In the end, perhaps what
is most significant and remarkable about this book is that it has seen the light
of day. It got published. Could it be that there is still hope for reasonable,
open debate about the right courses of action in the Middle East? The authors
have been and will continue to be vilified as anti-Semitic or worse. They are
owed a debt of gratitude for having the courage to stand up and to refuse to be
silenced.
Other Torrents
by John J Mearsheimer, Stephen M Walt
Genocide & War Crimes | Israel & Palestine | Middle East | Politics & Government | Politics & Social Sciences | War & Crisis | 17 kb/s opus transcoded from CD | embedded chapter index and cover
ogg | 1 comment
Politics/Sociology
144.3 MiB
0
83
by John J Mearsheimer, Stephen M Walt
Farrar, Straus and Giroux, September 2, 2008
pdf | 0 comments
Historical, Politics/Sociology
8.8 MiB
vinko
0
33