The Slings & Arrows Comic Guide
By David Roach, Steve Whitaker, Frank Plowright, William Jobbie, Win Wiacek, Nigel Fletcher, Howard Stangroom, Jenni Cole, Guy Lawley, Hassan Yusuf, Gerard Kingdon, Fiona Clements, Fiona Jerome, David Braysher, Adrian Snowdon, Andrew Littlefield
Language: English
Category: Ebook - Art
Categories: Art/Photography
Uploader: HappyJoy3
Uploaded At: 2022-03-24 01:49:06
2-1-2003, Top Shelf Productions, comprehensive alphabetical prose reviews of fifty plus years of comics, second edition
Description
Oh my God, I loved this book so, so much, and grabbed it off my bookshelf over and over again for years. It's an attempt by Frank Plowright and his reading crew to "Roger Ebert" the American comics field with an 800-page tome of reviews and analysis. You just can't believe how much ground this book covers and how many comics these writers must have read to make it. If you can name it, it's probably here.
You'll find, for example, three or four tight pages written about Action Comics highlighting all the key eras and storylines, making comments about which aspects work better than others. Then they end each entry with numbers (or the entire series) listed as "recommended". This is the second edition, so they've worked out some of the bugs and expanded their first attempt by nearly a thousand titles. Kids comics, independent, old dusty westerns, obscure, short series and lengthy, ongoing serials. It's a hell of a record of comics publishing from the 1930s to the early 2000s, and a real cultural education. The writing is solid, and they seem to really have a grasp on how comics work, when they work and when they don't. It's very entertaining to just browse and makes a hell of a companion to, say, The Comic Book History of Comics. Of course, those interested in earlier Golden or Silver age comics will be in hog heaven.
Couple of caveats here:
1 -- I have no idea if I've categorized this book correctly. ebooks-art. Comics IS art, but maybe that's supposed to be coffee table books about Picasso or something. I considered ebooks-recreation. I could still put it under comics/graphic novels I suppose, but it is a prose book about comics, not comics itself.
2 -- I can't tell how useful this will be in digital form. It's a reference book, and I'm pretty sure there's no way to look something up alphabetically in a cbz file without just having to click through hundreds of pages of other reviews. The joy I got out of it was flipping through the physical copy for interesting entries that caught my eye, or reading the authors' opinions on stuff I'd already read. As a digital file, it may be more difficult to target a specific book you want to research.
3 -- As a reference, it's twenty years out of date. You are not going to get the bulk of the graphic novel movement reflected here as it was only about a half-decade old when this book was published. I also don't imagine it will ever be updated because the need for the thing has been fully absorbed into multiple online resources. It's a fantastic source to scour the world of eighties and nineties formative graphic novels. There are entries titled "Eclipse Graphic Novels", for example, that throw in one entry all of that company's efforts to put a complete story into something with a spine - however few milimeters that spine might have been - and give each one a couple of sentences. I imagine it would come in handy while browsing the selections here on Myanonymouse.