The Quest for the Missing Girl
Language: English
Category: Manga - Comics/Graphic Novels
Categories: Crime, Mystery
Uploader: morrolan99
Uploaded At: 2022-02-21 02:02:59
Manga, Ponent Mon
Description
Mountaineer Shiga made a promise to his best friend following his tragic death in the Himalayas - now 12 years later he is called upon to honor that promise. When 15-year-old student Megumi fails to arrive home from school her mother calls on her dead husband's best friend for help. Shiga abandons his mountain refuge and enters the city to look for the girl - and with the police investigation at a standstill, Shiga has to go it alone.
From Publishers Weekly
Given that Taniguchi is the creator of and artist for many accomplished works of nouvelle manga such as The Walking Man and Ice Wanderer, this mystery manga falls short. The rather uninventive story line finds mountaineer Shiga traveling to Tokyo to find his friend's 15-year-old daughter, who has gone missing. Taniguchi, whose usual work reflects a fascination and great respect for nature and the overwhelming feelings that it can conjure, feels out of step with this book. The project excels in the mountain scenes and flashbacks, but flattens out in the flashy lights of Tokyo. Like Shiga, Taniguchi seems to feel out of place with the big city, outside of and uncomfortable with its rhythms. Very much a product of its time (Quest was first published in Japan in 1999), Taniguchi treats compensated dating (a practice of older men giving younger women gifts in exchange for companionship or sex, common in Japan in the 1990s) with a heavy hand. He also implements larger-than-life scenarios that, while staples in manga, feel clumsy in his hand. Taniguchi's art is ever beautiful, but like the storytelling here, it simply doesn't grip the reader the way his other works do. (Dec.)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From an Amazon review of this book: (note from uploader: this review is cut for brevity and spoilers)
4.0 out of 5 stars Interesting, intriguing, very adult, but not quite among his best ~
Reviewed in the United States on October 14, 2012
I have to say that A Zoo in Winter and A Distant Neighborhood are better manga than this. (See: A Zoo In Winter and A Distant Neighborhood, Vol. 1 ). But if one enjoys more 'adult' themes in manga (not R rated stuff). The themes Taniguchi uses typically cover relationships. There are themes of family, friends, love, and loss. One of the interesting aspects of Taniguchi's writing is that it seems he puts something of himself into his works.
In The Quest for the Missing Girl, Taniguchi seems a bit more distant in his writing. The plot and premise are very interesting, and cover a subject very hush hush in Japanese society: youth prostitution. In this manga, the protagonist is Shiga, a man who lives a solemn life in the mountains of rural Japan. He lives for mountain climbing. In an odd twist of fate, his old friend died while on a climb that Shiga refused to join. Shiga was grief and guilt stricken, but vowed to always look after his friend's wife and daughter. The daughter and the missing girl is Megumi. Very early on the reader discovers that her disappearance is connected to teenage prostitution. Shiga sets out for Tokyo to discover her whereabouts. Along the way he tackles the search as if it were a climb: always moving steadily forward with nearly mindless resolution.
All criticism aside, this is an excellent manga that delves into taboo territory for the Japanese public. I applaud the author for going against the grain, and using manga as the medium to do so. His works are complex and solidly written. Though the character drawings all seem similar to characters from other Taniguchi manga (it seems he only uses 8 female faces), he puts enough written dialogue personality into each so they don't come off as too similar except in appearance. The drawing style is crisp and clean, and as far as manga goes, Taniguchi tends to use restraint. Often the characters are standing in relaxed poses or sitting and conversing; very different than most modern manga where characters almost always seem to have to be in a state of motion.
I do recommend this manga heartily. If it were any other author/artist I would be listing five stars. But knowing Taniguchi can do better (and has done better), I felt it not up to his usual high standards. Check out the other two listings. Personally I liked A Zoo in Winter better, but they are both wonderful stories.
Scanned by Me and Edited by Kitakevo