CLAMP in Context: A Critical Study of the Manga and Anime

id: 706283 not VIP Open in MaM

By Dani Cavallaro

Language: English

Category: Ebook - General Non-fic

Categories: Art/Photography

Size: 3.2 MiB azw Files: 1

Uploader: morrolan99

Uploaded At: 2021-03-13 06:01:27

CLAMP, Manga, Anime.

Description

From the top rated Amazon Review for this book:
"Let me first say this: I have read every work by CLAMP, I own all of their art books, compilations, interviews, etc., so I am familiar with all of the same material Cavallaro was pulling from. I was a fan of her work with Miyazaki (and even built off some of her scholarship to publish my own work on Miyazaki) but this was a major disappointment.

Cavarallo chooses to focus on certain themes throughout CLAMP's work, but instead of a thoughtful, in-depth look at how those themes develop through their work, we get instead a strange mish-mash of 'big series' to focus on; much space is devoted to Tsubasa...and not just the manga. In fact, much space is devoted to a lot of material outside of CLAMP's manga, including Code Geass, which CLAMP designed the characters for and then largely had little to do with.

The themes Cavarllo chooses to explore are largely uninteresting in comparison to the rich material she has to work with; interdimensional travel is discussed, as is a more successful chapter that delves into humans' relationship with technology, and a less successful chapter regarding CLAMP's "core philosophy," as she reads it, is kicked around, but the whole task (which is done in a superfluously wordy way, almost as if the work is satirizing academic writing instead of actually participating in the scholarship) comes off as superficial: long tracks of her book merely recap events in certain series, and a whole page is devoted to just listing characters from Tsubasa that appear in other works (why? to what end or purpose?), giving the reader the sense that desperate space filler was needed.

This book gives you the impression that we're going to get an interesting discussion of much of CLAMP's work; you won't. In fact, some series which play a significant role in their body of work are never even touched upon - "Legal Drug," which, in three slim volumes, lays the foundation for xxxHOLIC (which also gets a fair amount of discussion) is only discussed, in passing (just name dropped) three times - no kidding. Check the index. It's existence is at least acknowledged, but that's it, and worse, a large portion of other series suffer from this same slight.

Possibly the worst offense about this book is that it gives no time or detail to one of the more complex issues in CLAMP's work: same sex relationships. Certainly, if an author is choosing not to focus on this aspect in favor of writing about other things, the author can't be blamed; you can't fault a comedy for not being a tragedy. But, for a work that sets itself up as putting "CLAMP in Context," as the title describes, this issue - which plays out all the way from their first series (RG Veda) to their current (Gate 7 and Drug & Drop) should have been addressed in a meaningful way - not outright ignored.

Overall, if you're looking for thoughtful scholarship on CLAMP in terms of the body of their work, this isn't it. If you're looking for some (mildly) interesting discussion of xxxHOLIC, Tsubasa, or Chobits (stay away from the X section entirely - it's a mess) then you may get something from this book. Again, Cavallaro's work on Miyazaki (where she DOES successfully go through the themes from the beginning of his work to the present) is FAR better. This book is a rushed mess of scholarship; hopefully someone else will come forward with something better to offer for English-speaking academics."


AZW, Retail rip

Other Torrents