Class Struggle

id: 704289 not VIP Open in MaM

By Bertell Ollman, The Avalon Hill Game Co

Language: English

Category: Ebook - Recreation

Categories: RPG

Size: 2.7 MiB pdf Files: 2

Uploader: professordan

Uploaded At: 2021-03-04 17:28:30

1978, Board Game, PnP, Gameplay 2–6 Players 90 Min Playing Time Age: 12+ Weight: 1.65 / 5 , Marx, Socialism, Union, Workers Movement, Monopoly, Occupy, 99%, 1%, Same Mechanics As Monopoly

Description

2–6 Players
90 Min
Playing Time
Age: 12+
Weight: 1.65 / 5


The Story of Class Struggle, America's Most Popular Marxist Board Game
BY Keith Plocek
August 12, 2014

https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/c_fill,g_auto,h_1248,w_2220/f_auto,q_auto,w_1100/v1555922410/shape/mentalfloss/classstruggle_640.jpg" alt="" />

The box for the Class Struggle board game features Karl Marx arm-wrestling Nelson Rockefeller. They’re using their left arms, so of course Marx is winning. Inside the box, a pile of Chance Cards includes messages such as “You are treating your class allies very badly” and “Your son has become a follower of Reverend Moon.” The ultimate goal of the game is to avoid nuclear war and win the revolution.

When the game was released in 1978, the U.S.A. and U.S.S.R. were locked in the Cold War and the specter of communism was still scary to the average American. Even then, Class Struggle sold around 230,000 copies. Before it went out of print, it was translated into Italian, German, French and Spanish.

https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/c_fit,f_auto,fl_lossy,q_auto,w_728/v1555922410/shape/mentalfloss/classstrugglecenter.jpg?itok=wOLAtIBx" alt="" />

Just how did this game become so popular? The story begins with a quirky Marxist professor trying to change jobs and ends with him getting sucked into the very system he was trying to subvert.

Professor Bertell Ollman had been teaching at New York University for a decade when he was offered the opportunity to chair the University of Maryland’s political science department, pending approval from the provost. The possibility of a noted Marxist scholar heading up a university department was not one to be ignored by the D.C. press, and they hopped on the story with a quickness today’s political bloggers would appreciate. Maryland’s governor and state senators started weighing in, and the approval process slowed way, way down.

Around the same time, Ollman was researching board games, in search of a socialist alternative to Monopoly. As he discusses in his 1983 memoir, Class Struggle Is the Name of the Game, Ollman learned Monopoly was actually based on The Landlord Game, which was invented in 1903 by a Quaker named Elizabeth Magie.

The original version had a different message, however, and as late as 1925 the game included the following instructions: “Monopoly is designed to show the evil resulting from the institution of private property. At the start of the game, every player is provided with the same chance of success as every other player. The game ends with one person in possession of all the money.”

Of course the Parker Brothers version that inflames family arguments today has flipped the script, which left Ollman pondering just how he could make a game that gives players equal chances yet still teaches them about the inequalities of capitalism. Then came his breakthrough. “What if the players are not individuals, but classes?” he writes. “One could make capitalists and workers roughly equal in power, though of course the sources of their power are very different. The game could even explore these different sources of power, and when and how they are used. The game could deal with the class struggle.”

Ollman had his game, whose rules involve two to six players taking on the roles of capitalists, workers, farmers, small businesspeople, professionals, and students. They move around the board while dealing with elections, strikes, wars, and whatever the Chance Cards throw their way, including, “Yesterday you shook hands with Republicrat Senator Kennewater, and you believed him when he said he is the workingman’s candidate. Lose 1 asset for being so gullible.”

https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/c_fit,f_auto,fl_lossy,q_auto,w_728/v1555922409/shape/mentalfloss/classstrugglechancecards.jpg?itok=6qe4ABtR" alt="" />

 
Keith Plocek
The box for the Class Struggle board game features Karl Marx arm-wrestling Nelson Rockefeller. They’re using their left arms, so of course Marx is winning. Inside the box, a pile of Chance Cards includes messages such as “You are treating your class allies very badly” and “Your son has become a follower of Reverend Moon.” The ultimate goal of the game is to avoid nuclear war and win the revolution.

When the game was released in 1978, the U.S.A. and U.S.S.R. were locked in the Cold War and the specter of communism was still scary to the average American. Even then, Class Struggle sold around 230,000 copies. Before it went out of print, it was translated into Italian, German, French and Spanish.

 


Just how did this game become so popular? The story begins with a quirky Marxist professor trying to change jobs and ends with him getting sucked into the very system he was trying to subvert.

Professor Bertell Ollman had been teaching at New York University for a decade when he was offered the opportunity to chair the University of Maryland’s political science department, pending approval from the provost. The possibility of a noted Marxist scholar heading up a university department was not one to be ignored by the D.C. press, and they hopped on the story with a quickness today’s political bloggers would appreciate. Maryland’s governor and state senators started weighing in, and the approval process slowed way, way down.

Around the same time, Ollman was researching board games, in search of a socialist alternative to Monopoly. As he discusses in his 1983 memoir, Class Struggle Is the Name of the Game, Ollman learned Monopoly was actually based on The Landlord Game, which was invented in 1903 by a Quaker named Elizabeth Magie.

The original version had a different message, however, and as late as 1925 the game included the following instructions: “Monopoly is designed to show the evil resulting from the institution of private property. At the start of the game, every player is provided with the same chance of success as every other player. The game ends with one person in possession of all the money.”

Of course the Parker Brothers version that inflames family arguments today has flipped the script, which left Ollman pondering just how he could make a game that gives players equal chances yet still teaches them about the inequalities of capitalism. Then came his breakthrough. “What if the players are not individuals, but classes?” he writes. “One could make capitalists and workers roughly equal in power, though of course the sources of their power are very different. The game could even explore these different sources of power, and when and how they are used. The game could deal with the class struggle.”

Ollman had his game, whose rules involve two to six players taking on the roles of capitalists, workers, farmers, small businesspeople, professionals, and students. They move around the board while dealing with elections, strikes, wars, and whatever the Chance Cards throw their way, including, “Yesterday you shook hands with Republicrat Senator Kennewater, and you believed him when he said he is the workingman’s candidate. Lose 1 asset for being so gullible.”

 


What Ollman didn’t have was any practical knowledge of small business, and the first run of the game was destined for dusty storage until a New York Post article picked up the story and attached it to the University of Maryland controversy. Articles soon followed in the Chicago Sun-Times, The New York Times, The Washington Post and The Baltimore Sun. The Village Voice called the game a “shade prim” for saying marijuana and alcohol were opiates of the people.

The game was a hit, and Class Struggle started appearing on shelves alongside Monopoly. But Ollman soon learned getting orders was not the same thing as getting paid, and the Marxist scholar quickly became an expert in how small businesspeople get squeezed. Many radical bookstores never paid him for the games, and relations became strained with his initial investors, who also happened to be his good friends. Bad publicity followed when a small group of striking workers at Brentano’s Bookstore asked him to pull the game and then used his refusal to promote their own fight.

“Even my political commitment was beginning to fray at the edges,” he writes in his memoir. “I had always been delighted by each downturn of sales reported in the marketplace — ‘People buying less junk,’ I thought. Now, the same news appeared somehow threatening. I caught myself thinking, ‘If the collapse of capitalism could wait just a little longer, until we got our business on its feet.’”

Success was always right around the corner, but the costs kept rising. When Ollman and his cohorts did not have enough money for the second run of the game, they seized upon a small difference in quality to refuse payment to the manufacturer. Lawsuits ensued. (A word of advice: Never go into business with a Marxist.) The University of Maryland’s provost punted the decision about the political science department to his successor, who denied Ollman’s appointment. More lawsuits. Ollman’s game was still selling, but the enterprise was sinking further into debt.

“Being broke is bad enough,” he writes. “Being broke and mistaken for a millionaire—by everyone but the bank, that is—is about as funny as coughing up blood.”

Ollman was grinding his teeth so badly that four of them cracked, and after three years of struggle, the professor and his partners sold the game to Avalon Hill, a company that specialized in war games. The game disappeared in 1994.

https://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/c_fit,f_auto,fl_lossy,q_auto,w_728/v1555922409/shape/mentalfloss/classstrugglesquare.jpg?itok=HWYBLLEt" alt="" />

As for Ollman, he is still a professor at New York University, and when asked about the game’s legacy, he tells Mental Floss:

“As long as there is a class struggle (and there certainly is in the U.S., where it may have gotten more intense, especially during the current economic crisis), there is a great need to help young people understand what it is, how it works, and where they fit into it. They are certainly not going to learn any of this from the mainstream media or in most of their formal education. The game could still contribute to this important work.”

Just watch out for Republicrat Senator Kennewater.

All photos by Keith Ploceck

This Avalon Hill game is a vehicle for instructing students (there is a classroom section in the rules) on why Marxism is superior. The Workers move around a board while trying to survive against the Capitalist player who control everything. As the Workers unite they take power from the Capitalist player but if they do not suceed in uniting the Capitalist will win.

The Marxist politics are very up front in this game in presentation and in the suggested reading in the rules. A surprising publication from a war game company

Designer Bertell Ollman
Artist N/A
Publisher The Avalon Hill Game Co, Class Struggle, Inc., Didacta, Metracon, Mondadori Giochi

From The Guardian:

Terrible educational board games are a blight on us all. Everyone's played them: invariably, the game itself is little more than a reskinned snakes-and-ladders, but rather than climbing ladders, informative captions combine learning with fun. In theory.

"Witches have prophesied that no man of woman born can kill you! Move forward three spaces."



"Archduke Franz Ferdinand has been assassinated in Sarajevo by Gavrilo Princip. Move backwards five squares."

"You've arrived in the uterus, but there's no egg to fertilise. Skip a turn."

It's not hard to pin down why the games are so unfulfilling. For one, they're basically pure chance, to the extent that even an eight-year-old on a rainy Thursday afternoon can tell that nothing they do has any effect on the outcome. For another, the actual game has little to do with what it's professing to teach: you're all just rolling dice.

But sometimes, people go the extra mile, and it makes all the difference.

Class Struggle is a faintly ridiculous educational board game, created by the New York University politics professor Bertell Ollman in 1978. Its aim, according to the basic rules available on Ollman's site, is to teach students "aged 8 to 80" about Marxism. "The object of the game is to win the revolution… "

"Until then, classes – represented by different players – advance around the board, making and breaking alliances, and picking up strengths and weaknesses that determine the outcome of the elections and general strikes which occur along the way."

The game is still not exactly fun, but it approaches its goal with such charm that it's hard not to be won over. Take the chance cards – a different deck for the workers and capitalists, representing random events in the game.

"You have just been laid off from work," reads one worker card. "If you blame yourself, or foreign competition, or the Blacks, or Jews, move two spaces back. If you blame the capitalists, move two spaces ahead."

"You are caught feeling sorry for the workers," says a capitalist card. "Victory in class struggle comes to people who think about their own class. Miss two turns at the dice."

Impressively, even the rules of the game serve to underscore the message it's trying to send. Take how the players decide who is to play as the capitalist:

"Individual players cannot choose their class," the rules state. "In real life, this is usually determined by the kind of family into which one is born. In "Class Struggle" too it is chance that decides. Throw the genetic (or luck-of-birth) die, the one with the symbols on it, to see who plays what class."

In the full rules (the game includes a "basic" and "full" rule book, as well as a booklet designed to expand on the lessons imparted within), the order that the players roll the luck of birth die is determined by their social privilege. The whiter, straighter and more male you are, the more chances you get to become the capitalist. Just like in real life!

In its own way, Class Struggle makes a good case for the advantages of using games, not just to teach, but also to persuade. Playing a game involves playing inside a rule-set devised by someone else. If those rules mimic the real world, they can embed simplifications which would never pass muster when laid out in a more straightforward manner.

Take Class Struggle's rule that only the capitalists can trigger nuclear war, never the workers or, in a subtler fashion, Sim City's modelling of crime (poverty makes crime, and police stop it).

The fans the game has won - which include libertarian economics blog Marginal Revolution - are drawn to it by the the charm and sensibility of a slightly eccentric professor from the 1970s. However gently persuasive its message and skillfully crafted its game dynamics, it seems unlikely to have won many people round to the cause of revolutionary marxism.

Other Torrents