Nietzsche the Aristocratic Rebel: Intellectual Biography and Critical Balance-sheet

id: 657018 not VIP Open in MaM

By Domenico Losurdo

Language: English

Category: Ebook - Philosophy

Categories: Philosophy

Size: 4.1 MiB pdf Files: 1

Uploader: professordan

Uploaded At: 2020-09-08 03:41:20

You know that book you've been waiting to make connection between Nietzsche and Marx? This is THE Book! - 1054 pages - Publisher Brill Academic Pub (November 20, 2019)

Description

Hardcover : 1054 pages
ISBN-10 : 9004270949
ISBN-13 : 978-9004270947
Publisher : Brill Academic Pub (November 20, 2019)

This is Nietzsche as you never saw before

Introduction to the English-Language Edition (excerpt)
Harrison Fluss
After narrating the long reception of Nietzsche from Emma Goldman to Stanley
Cavell, Jennifer Ratner-Rosenhagen concludes her American Nietzsche in a
manner sympathetic to the pragmatist reading of the philosopher’s work:There
is not one correct understanding of Nietzsche, any more than there is one true
philosophical approach. What defines Nietzsche – if anything can define him –
is the fundamental ‘indeterminacy, perspectivalism and heterogeneity’ at the
heart of his philosophy, making him eminently congenial to the American traditions
of liberalism and pluralism.1 Nietzsche, thus, is as American as apple
pie.
What Ratner-Rosenhagen ignores, however, are the other dimensions to
Nietzsche’s thinking, dimensions that are just as relevant to the story of an
American Nietzsche. Nietzsche’s responses to race, slavery, and abolitionism
are left out of the account, since the Americanism Ratner-Rosenhagen presents
us with is thoroughly de-contextualised. It is an Americanism clipped of its
apparent inconsistencies and paradoxes, embodied, for instance, in Nietzsche’s
American precursor, the liberal Emerson. Ratner-Rosenhagen starts her narrative
with Nietzsche’s love for Emerson, but one should note that Nietzsche
not only read Emerson the individualist, but Emerson the elitist and heroworshipper
as well.2 Nietzsche considered himself to be ‘a liberal’ at times, but
he was also a theorist who promoted hierarchy and rank-ordering.3 How can
the ostensibly progressive values of liberalism and pluralism then be united
with the elitist politics Nietzsche represented? Indeed, how can such authoritarian
values be compatible with the picture of an anti-foundationalist Nietzsche
that concludes Ratner-Rosenhagen’s book?
Of course, such an objection to Nietzsche’s elitism has already been dismissed
as irrelevant countless times, since, according to this wide-ranging academic
consensus, the importance of Nietzsche lies in his more rarefied ideas
and not in his politics. The political dimensions of his thinking are typically
phased out in both continental and analytical philosophy circles. For instance,
the Cambridge translation of Nietzsche’s writings from his later notebooks
(materials which were originally edited under the title The Will to Power) is
introduced by the volume’s editors without considering his political views or
statements, as if these were extraneous to his more properly philosophical
concerns. Hence, Nietzsche’s ideas on the nature of reality, epistemology, and
language are highlighted for discussion, but not his criticisms of politics, modern
decadence, economics, and criminality. These more terrestrial and topical
dimensions of the notebooks are treated as if they were bereft of philosophical
significance.4
In this domestication process of Nietzsche, the Dionysian and creative meditations
on the nature of perception, art, language, and morals, are kept at
safe distance from his ‘timely’ interests in historical events, the domestic and
foreign policy of the Second Reich, or even a science as dismal as political economy.
But, while Nietzsche is said to lack an essence, this decontextualised
portrait ironically essentialises him into a timeless philosopher abstracted from
history. As an atemporal philosopher, Nietzsche can become a kind of conceptual
tool-box wherein academics, scholars, and others can cherry-pick what
they want, leaving the potentially offensive elements of Nietzsche behind. The
success behind Nietzsche as an empty signifier arguably lies in how people can
see in him whatever they would like to see.
The analytical and continental decontamination of Nietzsche has not gone
unchallenged in recent years. Several studies exist which deny the bifurcation
of Nietzsche’s philosophical thinking from his politics, demonstrating an
indelible link between the two. Others have also challenged the attempted synthesis
between Nietzsche’s thinking and progressive ideas, a synthesis which
in the end makes a mockery of both what Nietzsche argued for and those progressive
ideas he scorned. We can offer here a brief – but by no means exhaustive
– list of some of the most interesting approaches to Nietzsche as a highly
political and anti-democratic thinker. These include Fredrick Appel’s Nietzsche
Contra Democracy; William Altman’s Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche: The Philosopher
of the Second Reich; Malcolm Bull’s Anti-Nietzsche; Don Dombowsky’s place:
Nietzschean Heroism in Popular Culture; the late Stanley Rosen’s Mask of
Enlightenment: Nietzsche’s Zarathustra; and Geoff Waite’s Nietzsche’s Corps/e:
Aesthetics, Politics, and the Spectacular Techno-Culture of Everyday Life.5 These
studies, together with the book being introduced here, have been truly transformational
for how we read Nietzsche.
Domenico Losurdo’s intellectual biography is part of this new wave of criticism
and helped to inspire a fair amount of it when the biography first came
out in Italian, and then in its German, French, and Portuguese translations.6
But what makes Losurdo’s study so monumental is that it is not another interpretation
of Nietzsche, but a total reconstruction of Nietzsche’s main project.
It deserves the title of a reconstruction from its immense scope, since Losurdo
attempts not only to explicate Nietzsche’s ideas, but also the overall context in
which they arose.
But where does Nietzsche’s ultimate coherence lie for Losurdo? What is it
that persists through the vicissitudes of his written corpus? What is it that
endures from his intellectual life? The locus of meaning in Nietzsche’s writing
is revealed to be, according to Losurdo, in ‘his constant eye on social conflict
and the threat of socialism’ (p. 289). Politics is the main organon of Nietzsche’s
thinking.
This does not bode well for the consensus view of Nietzsche: the antidogmatic
and anti-systematic thinker par excellence, with no one fixed doctrine
or point of view. To think Nietzsche is to think many Nietzsches.7 That is why the apparent boldness of Losurdo’s claim needs to be understood. Losurdo
is not saying that Nietzsche’s writings on philosophy, science, and art
come with secondary political effects or that they are linked to Nietzsche’s own
peculiar brand of nineteenth-century prejudices. Losurdo argues that these
discussions of philosophy, science, and art are, for Nietzsche, already political
discussions and are framed by a distinct political perspective. Without considering
the meaning of that perspective, Nietzsche’s supposedly more rarefied
interventions must remain, to a large degree, unintelligible. For Losurdo, it is
the fundamentally undemocratic intent of Nietzsche’s thinking that gives his
reflections on philosophy, art, and science their real rigour, significance and
unity.
This is the research programme with which Losurdo presents us. But it is
important to state, from the outset, some qualifying remarks before introducing
some of the main contours of the biography. Losurdo is not simply writing
a polemic against Nietzsche. Even though he is portraying Nietzsche warts and
all, his book is not a hateful screed, but a study that sets out to restore Nietzsche
as a great thinker, however disturbing and reactionary he may be. Losurdo
wants us to learn from Nietzsche while being critical, and we will see what this
conceptual surplus of Nietzsche entails for critical readers below. Second, Losurdo
avoids the mistake of seeing Nietzsche’s thought as a direct foreshadowing
of National Socialism and argues that it is wrong to write the history of Nietzsche’s
ideas with the Third Reich functioning as a future anterior. Instead, one
must first situate Nietzsche’s ideas in their correct historical context, that is,
not in the Third, but in the Second Reich. And, while there are echoes of Nietzscheanism
in German fascism,8 it is not an unmediated process.
Losurdo starts with Nietzsche’s so-called early period as a young Wagnerite.
He demonstrates the essentially political nature of his lectures on Socrates and
Tragedy, and what would become The Birth of Tragedy. These are works written
in the shadow of what Nietzsche saw as a disaster of cataclysmic proportions,
a disaster that may have augured the end of civilisation as he had known it.
From the descriptions of Jacob Burckhardt and Nietzsche’s letters as an orderly
in the Franco-Prussian war, we see the sense of excitement, dread, and horror

Other Torrents