Marx: A Radical Critique
Language: English
Category: Ebook - Pol/Soc/Relig
Categories: Politics/Sociology
Uploader: Jamilah
Uploaded At: 2019-09-14 23:23:35
marx, critique, socialism, 28 March 1988, sociology, economics, politics
Description
Customer reviews:
"If you have ever wondered why the Russian revolution did not turn out as Marx predicted, this is the book for you.
A highly informative read. Recommended for those who are familiar with Marx and/or Marxist theory already, it is highly Useful to students of or those interested in sociology, economics and politics. Carter criticises Marx on his own territory, pointing out the faults in marxist theory, rather than empirically criticising him. He explains how the totalitariansim resulting from the Russian Revolution was entirely due to Marx's theory, rather than it being the result of a band of dictators hijcaking a "genuinely socialist" revolution. The book includes chapters on Economics (Crisis, Value and Profit), Politics (The State and Society), Sociology (Class and Class Consciousness) and History, as well as a concluding chapter (A Radical Alternative), which indicates some of the directions the radical Left need to move in if what they desire is an egilatarian society under the control of the masses, rather than one dominated by a techno-beauracratic elite, which, as Carter demonstrates, is what Marx's theory has led to wherever it has been practised.
Highly recommended for anyone who considers themselves to belong to the revolutionary Left, whether anarchists or socialists."
"This is a great book for people on the radical left who want a critical engagement with marxism, but not from bourgeois thinkers. Alan Carter goes through major areas/claims in marxist thought and critically reviews them. For anti-capitalists familiar with stalinist regimes, you understand how Marxist thought can and does become an unquestioned religion; A holy text that predicts the revolution. This book is the opposite of how vulgar marxists approach marx. It is very analytical in arguing with major tenets of marxism, such as the economic-reductionist relationship between the mode of production and the superstructure, and how marx's Labor Theory of Value can not deal with monopolistic conditions of actually existing capitalism and protectionist pricing.
My favorite part was how Carter showed historical materialism to be a reductionist, unidirectional version of history. Alan Carter evaluates marxist theory according to our current situation of global warming and resource depletion (an up to date understanding of science). For such dedicated "scientists", today's marxists are disengaged with the current ecological/resource situation. Criticizing marx as a thinker embedded in a booming industrial society, Carter points out the major flaw with historical materialism: The idea that advanced-capitalist industrialism is the necessary precondition for socialism/communism. The historical materialist path is now ecologically suicidal, and even impossible as earth's resources reach peaks. Therefore, a socialism will not be ushered in the way historical materialists claim it will happen."