Kent State: What Happened and Why

id: 466340 not VIP Open in MaM

By James A Michener

Narrator: Larry McKeever

Language: English

Category: Audiobook - History

Categories: Historical

Size: 659.3 MiB mp3 Files: 10

Uploader: solenopsist

Uploaded At: 2018-10-09 23:21:38

64kbps, unabridged, separated using Overdrive Chapterize tool, length: 23 hours and 57 minutes

Description

A probing and dramatic study of the tragic events leading up to the killing of four students by National Guardsmen at Kent State University in the spring of 1970.

The NYT Review (1971)
James A. Michener, working with a group of researchers and after ex haustive interviewing, has compiled a detailed account of the grim events that ended in the shooting of four students at Kent State University in May, 1970. Each of his book's 559 pages is crammed with evidence, statements, analyses, and most of those pages suggest also a prodigious effort, on Mr. Michener's part, to achieve even‐handed treatment of his harrowing material. Yet, “Kent State: What Happened and Why” seems to me to exemplify much of what has gone wrong between America and its children—much, indeed, of the at titudes that helped produce the ter rible, senseless deaths at Kent State. (Mr. Michener will not call them murders or even manslaughter, only “an accident, deplorable and tragic.”)

The problem is certainly not in the research. Mr. Michener and his team seem to have tracked down every possible lead, talked to every con ceivable informant. As in any work of massed detail, some of the min utiae seems irrelevant, and only de lays the dread inevitable march of the action up Blanket Hill to the point of the shooting. (“There was a single shot—some people heard it as two almost simultaneous shots— then a period of silence lasting about two seconds, then a prolonged but thin fusillade, not a single angry burst, lasting about eight seconds, then another silence, and two final shots. The shooting had covered thir teen seconds, which is a very long time under such circumstances, and fifty‐five M‐1 bullets seem to have been discharged, plus five pistol shots and the single burst from a shotgun.”)

Neither is the writing at fault. Like the practiced novelist he is, Mr. Michener weaves from one side to the other and back, breaks and builds suspense, drops hints and openings to be followed later, flashes back, steps aside, moves into the minds of ibis characters, in order to keep things moving. This sometimes gets a little obvious, and there is much dialogue that is, at best, recon structed.

In other respects the sheer mass of the thing commands respect. One gets a sense, for instance, of what it is like for a Guardsman to peer along the restricted, straight‐ahead sight lines permitted by a gas mask while a crowd is gathering all around; that is the kind of detail that tells a great deal about what happened, that tense weekend following Mr. Nixon's speech on Cambodia.

Nor has Mr. Michener neglected the context or the background of events. Town and campus relation ships; Kent State's academic and po litical position in Ohio; the history of student radicalism there; the tradi tions and regulations of the Ohio Na tional Guard—all these and many other tributary streams are explored. In fact, one of the major contribu tions Mr. Michener is able to make is to show that it was not particular ly surprising, as some have thought, that the shootings happened at Kent State, rather than on a better‐known or more “radicalized” campus.

Continue reading the main story
Advertisement

Continue reading the main story

Mr. Michener also explodes the more egregious myths that have gathered over the Kent State deaths. Radical blacks were not only not in volved in any of the weekend dem onstrations, but their campus leaders organized patrols to keep their fol lowers totally out of things. The re searchers found no evidence that the use of drugs by students had any thing to do with what happened. Mr. Michener angrily demolishes the sick eningly foul rumors about the four dead students that were spread and swallowed not just by ghouls but by supposedly decent people. And here is a summary of his findings on the shootings: “The National Guard was in control at all times . . . there was no sniper. . . . The Guard was in no mortal danger at the time of the firing . . . no student per formed any act on May 4 for which he deserved to be shot.”

So this is a detailed, painstaking, fair‐minded, skillful, often illuminat ing book, with whose assertions of fact it would be difficult to quarrel, and which is likely to remain the definitive account of what happened at Kent State. But that is not all Mr. Michener's book is; it is also an attempt to analyze, understand and describe that phenomenon of our time variously described as “student unrest,” “the youth revolt,” “the generation gap,” the “Movement,” or “the kids.”

The trouble can be spotted on Mr. Michener's very first page, where he speaks of “that enormous group of stable, solid young people who form the reliable central core of our great universities.” Mr. Midhener's colors are up the flagpole almost before he begins; we know at the outset of whom he approves (stable, solid, re liable) and despite his visible strug gle to be fair and impartial, the im pression grows throughout his book that that approval is a vital element of his book.

Early on, he attempts in some de tail to compare the new “life style” of some young people with an older “life style” that he sums up as fol lows: “a man's word is as good as his bond. If a man works he'll get ahead. America has usually tried to do the right thing. Get an education and you can accomplish anything. God is watching.” Mr. Michener says 90 per cent of Americans subscribe to that view, and he states flatly that it is “founded upon the accumu lated experience of mankind, and in the United States is influenced by our Puritan heritage.” After that, no amount of explanation, of why some students believe or behave otherwise is likely to command much sympathy for their point of view.

In fact, when Mr. Michener asks himself rhetorically,“Does adherence to the new life style predispose a participant toward an eventual form of dictatorship?” He decides that “the answer would appear to be yes.” Why? Among other reasons, because of the new life style's “tendency to accept unproved ideas” and its “yearning for simplistic solutions.” Plainly, Mr. Midhener does not con sider the notion “if a man works, he'll get ahead” either simplistic or an unproved idea; nor does he ques tion what “getting ahead” means, or is worth. Moreover, he fol lows his long discussion of the new style with a highly speculative dis cussion as to what extent its propa gation in the United States is fi nanced from Cuba.

It is Mr. Michener's privilege to approve what he approves, and in deed he may even be right, or more right than wrong. The problem is that his underlying assumptions of right and wrong ultimately sabotage the even‐handedness with which he has so obviously tried to write about Kent State; time and again, he just cannot bring himself to accept the logic of his own findings.

His account frequently calls atten tion, for instance, to the difficulties and confusions that resulted from the absence of President Robert White from the Kent State campus during the critical weekend; indeed, it will seem incredible to many that any college president would have left his campus in the troubled week end following the Cambodia speech. Yet, Mr. Michener states roundly that although it was a “tragedy” that Dr. White was not on hand, he “was absent on educational matters of the highest import and the entire Kent Community should have been proud that his counsel had been sought elsewhere.” One suspects the reason for such lenient judgment is that Mr. Michener already has observed that Dr. White “is a gentleman when the breed is going out of style.”

Here is another example. An un known student is properly charged by Mr. Michener with “a malicious act which had far‐reaching conse quences” for having used a bullhorn to spread information he knew to be false. On the same page‐295—he considers the inflammatory state ment of Gov. James Rhodes (then in the last stages of his losing primary campaign against Robert Taft Jr.), comparing some students to “brown shirts” and calling them “the worst type that we harbor in America.” This, concludes Mr. Michener, was “in the flamboyant tradition of Amer ican political leadership and cannot be unduly faulted for that.” Yet, he has already shown that the Governor's statement, delivered in Kent the morning after the burning of the R.O.T.C. building, had much to do with polarizing even “stable, solid” students against the authority represented by the National Guard.

After citing several examples of the insensitivity (never so described) of General Canter bury (the National Guard commander), and despite the fact that after his men had fired without orders the General had to be talked out of send ing them once again into ac tion on the same campus on the same day, Mr. Michener notes blandly: “One cannot help but feel sympathy for Canter bury, working under this cloud of misapprehension and uncertainty; given the circumstances, he conducted himself rather sensibly.”

So it is not surprising that despite all his own evidence that the Guard did not have to fire, was not ordered to fire, and had no students in front of it whose conduct warranted their being shot, Mr. Michener reports that “we cannot convince ourselves that murder was committed by the Guard . . . there was death, but not murder.”

Even so, it is astounding that he can ask rather calmly, on the next page “whether the death of four students should in some way be punished.” No, he concludes, it should not be, because of an Ohio law hold ing officers guiltless for killing anyone “in suppression of a riot.” The ultimate measure of Mr. Michener's book then follows in this tortured sentence: “It may be argued, as these conclusions do, that no riot existed on May 4, but a riotous condition did, and that would seem to justify application of the above law.” (The italics are the reviewer's.)

The law does not say any thing about a “riotous condition,” and it specifies that guilt is absolved only if the use of force has been “necessary and proper” which Mr. Michener has rather conclusively proved it was not; but no one is to be punished. There must, of course, be a last even‐handed admonition:

“The United States cannot allow young people to be shot down in its streets, for if this were to become common, a revulsion would result of such dimension as to sweep away our forms of government. Young people who brazenly defy soldiers, daring them to shoot, commit more than suicide; they commit a grave crime against organized society. And soldiers or policemen who fire without ultimate provocation run the grave risk of alienating the support which sustains them.”

Most of Mr. Michener's book is that of a humane and moderate man — who can, for in stance, be outraged at such people as the mother who told. her daughter that she should have been shot if she was demonstrating, and who well understands that it is “middle aged intransigence” to be so “irrationally opposed” to long hair and beards. Yet, at its core, his is the book of a man who is unable—to say unwilling would be unfair — to believe that there is anything really wrong with the “old life style” or that direct challenges to the authority behind it can ever be necessary or worth while. And the paragraph just quoted, which lies at the heart of Mr. Michener's conclusions, so lacks elementary humanity as to mock most of his obvious effort to understand—as if it were some strange psychiatric case —the “new life style.”

Is that paragraph, with its concerns only for “our forms of government,” “organized society” and, “the support which sustains” military force, all the old life style has to say, as its soldiers stand with smoking muzzles above the riddled bodies of its children? Is that really all there is to say? What price are we going to pay in this country to maintain not just law and order but the old life style?

That is the question James Michener's book really puts be fore us, and it finally suggests that maybe we are all going to have to come to Ruda Perry's answer. As one of Kent State's black leaders, he told Mr. Michener why no blacks had been involved in the fatal week end at Kent State:

“You could get five thousand white cats on that hill with the National Guard running around. But you couldn't get five blacks. What was the differ ence? Education. We had learned.”

Other Torrents