Framed: America's 51 Constitutions And The Crisis Of Governance
Narrator: A T Chandler
Language: English
Category: Audiobook - Pol/Soc/Relig
Categories: Politics/Sociology
Uploader: Mousse
Uploaded At: 2017-12-03 07:21:46
"Readers who think they know a lot about the Constitution will find out how much more they have to learn from this book." - Unabridged
Description
Framed America's 51 Constitutions And The Crisis Of Governance
Author Sanford Levinson
Narrator A T Chandler
MP3 32 kbps 16.000 kHz
17 Hours
Unabridged
Audible
Date March 2 2012
About The Author
Sanford Victor Levinson is a prominent American liberal law professor and acknowledged expert on Constitutional law and legal scholar and professor of government at the University of Texas Law School. He is notable for his criticism of the United States Constitution as well as excessive presidential power and has been widely quoted on such topics as the Second Amendment, gay marriage, nominations to the Supreme Court, and other legal issues. He has called for a Second Constitutional Convention of the United States.
In his widely acclaimed volume Our Undemocratic Constitution, Sanford Levinson boldly argued that our Constitution should not be treated with "sanctimonious reverence," but as a badly flawed document deserving revision. Now Levinson takes us deeper, asking what were the original assumptions underlying our institutions, and whether we accept those assumptions 225 years later.
In Framed, Levinson challenges our belief that the most important features of our constitutions concern what rights they protect. Instead, he focuses on the fundamental procedures of governance such as congressional bicameralism; the selection of the President by the electoral college, or the dimensions of the President's veto power - not to mention the near impossibility of amending the United States Constitution. These seemingly "settled" and "hardwired" structures contribute to the now almost universally recognized "dysfunctionality" of American politics.
Levinson argues that we should stop treating the United States Constitution as uniquely exemplifying the American constitutional tradition. We should be aware of the 50 state constitutions, often interestingly different - and perhaps better - than the national model. Many states have updated their constitutions by frequent amendment or by complete replacement via state constitutional conventions. California's ungovernable condition has prompted serious calls for a constitutional convention. This constant churn indicates that basic law often reaches the point where it fails and becomes obsolete. Given the experience of so many states, he writes, surely it is reasonable to believe that the U.S. Constitution merits its own updating.
Whether we are concerned about making America more genuinely democratic or only about creating a system of government that can more effectively respond to contemporary challenges, we must confront the ways our constitutions, especially the United States Constitution, must be changed in fundamental ways.
Customer Reviews
Readers who think they know a lot about the Constitution will find out how much more they have to learn from this book. Law Professor Sanford Levinson examines parts of the document few people pay attention to, and he compares the Constitution to state constitutions and to the constitutions in other countries.
In our era of political polarization, one thing that unites Americans across the spectrum is the perception that the federal government is profoundly dysfunctional. Only about one in ten Americans approve of the job Congress is doing, and trust in government is at historic lows.
Levinson has a simple thesis, namely that government failure is caused in part by the constitutional structure of government, at both the federal and state levels, and that as much attention should be paid to the 50 state documents that also make up American constitutionalism.
Americans hold the Constitution in high regard, so criticizing it is considered akin to radicalism if not disloyalty. Most would-be reformers of the political system shy away from trying to change the structure. Levinson recognizes the towering achievement the Constitution represented in the 18th century, but he also believes it needs to be updated to meet current conditions, which are quite different from those of 1787.
**********
Framed is nearly unique -- instead of delving into the endless debates over ambiguous clauses in our Constitution and its amendments, Levinson examines the unambiguous, "settled" rules that are baked into the original document, and he discusses whether they are worth their exalted status. Why, for example, do we need a constitutional amendment to change the date of Inauguration Day? Why is it so hard to make any changes to the composition of the undemocratic Senate?
Excellent read. Current and piercing. I second the author's call for a new constitutional convention.
***********
Levinson is one of our keenest observers of the US Constitution—in this book he explores our state constitutional traditions."
**********
This book was given to us as assigned reading for an American Politics class. Though the content is quite interesting, Levinson's writing style is difficult to get through and often detracts from the point he's trying to make. As long as one is accustomed to reading books written by lawyers, it really is a good read. For anyone else though... one classmate had to read every chapter three times to understand the content and it put most of my other classmates to sleep. Listening to the Audible version helped a lot and the person voicing it did a wonderful job.
**********
Alas, Levinson's discussion of this immense problem is limited to a couple of pages of Chapter 1. On page 29, he even lets another author, Daniel Rodriquez, define the problem: "[T]he basic range of policies and policy choices made by state and local officials dwarf (sic)--indeed always have dwarfed (sic)--national political activity." Ever since Tip O'Neill said, "All politics is local," that has been my observation, and why it should be a mystery to any other serious student of American history is beyond me.
In our dysfunctional national legislative family, 50 squabbling children (mostly bicameral state legislatures) individually devise their own conflicting "playground rules" and pry "lunch money" from their citizens (and then petition Congress via the IRS Form 1040, Schedule A to refund part of it), even though the U.S. Constitution gives only Congress the right to tax (and specifically only incomes at that). Not satisfied with salaries and perks provided by the IRS, the members of the parent Congress engorge themselves on generous "campaign contributions" from corporate members of the American Legislative Exchange Council, which has no allegiance to any state, and (given its tendency to hide profits offshore) probably not to the nation, either.
**********
Levinson wrote a thought provoking book which every citizen of this Republic should read. I agree with his proposal to hold a constitutional convention to rewrite our existing constitution which is out of date for the times in which we live. However, I to not share Levinsons' idea of more democracy to make our current problems go away or help government to solve them better. I think the framers were right. Most citizens cannot govern themselves so that is why they chose a republican form of government and made only one branch directly elected by the people. The problem with that idea was the rise of political parties shortly after the start of the new republican government. Political parties screwed up the checks and balances the framers devised to balance power and control special interest groups of citizens.
Levinson does point out many problems that need to be addressed, so I think it a good starting point for the new framers to work from.
**********
Fantastic book comparing US constitution to other constitutions to show laudable elements and other elements that Americans apparently would like to change based on very convincing evidence and argument. If you are concerned about the national political or governmental landscape in the US, you must arm yourself with this book.
**********
You want fundamental Constitutional reform? This book is amazing. It builds off of Levinson's last book, which is also fantastic (5 stars) -- Our Undemocratic Constitution: Where the Constitution Goes Wrong (And How We the People Can Correct It). Spoiler: he proposes the same solution. (i.e., a Constitutional Convention by a group of people picked by a lottery -- with many other great suggestions).
Other Torrents
by Sanford Levinson
narrated by A T Chandler
"Readers who think they know a lot about the Constitution will find out how much more they have to learn from this book." - Unabridged
m4b | 0 comments
Politics/Sociology
245.2 MiB
Mousse
0
37
by Sanford Levinson
narrated by A T Chandler
"Readers who think they know a lot about the Constitution will find out how much more they have to learn from this book." - Unabridged
m4a | 0 comments
Politics/Sociology
245.1 MiB
Mousse
0
14