CBC R1 - Massey Lectures - 2017 - Payam Akhavan - In Search of a Better World: A Human Rights Odyssey

id: 403557 not VIP Open in MaM

By CBC Radio, Payam Akhavan

Series: CBC Massey Lectures #53, CBC Ideas

Narrator: Payam Akhavan

Language: English

Category: Radio - Factual/Documentary

Categories: Factual News/Current Events

Size: 297.5 MiB mp3 Files: 8

Uploader: algernonRA

Uploaded At: 2017-11-16 02:51:45

Payam Akhavan's 2017 CBC Massey Lectures is a powerful survey of some of the major human rights struggles of our times - and what we can do about it

Description

CBC Massey Lectures 2017 - Payam Akhavan - In Search of a Better World: A
Human Rights Odyssey

A call to action for our times, Payam Akhavan's 2017 CBC Massey Lectures, "In
Search of a Better World: A Human Rights Odyssey", is a powerful survey of some
of the major human rights struggles of our times - and what we can do about it.

Renowned UN prosecutor and human rights scholar Payam Akhavan has encountered
the grim realities of contemporary genocide throughout his life and career.
Deceptive utopias, political cynicism, and public apathy, he says, have given
rise to major human rights abuses: from the religious persecution of Iranian
Bahá'ís that shaped his personal life, to the horrors of ethnic cleansing in
Yugoslavia, the genocide in Rwanda, and the rise of the Islamic State.

But he also reflects on the inspiring resilience of the human spirit, and the
reality that we need each other, to set us free from ideology and go about
building that better world.

A timely, essential, and passionate work of memoir and history, "In Search of a
Better World" is a tour-de-force by an internationally renowned human rights
lawyer.

"In Search of a Better World: A Human Rights Odyssey" is published by House of
Anansi Press.

The 2017 CBC Massey Lectures were broadcast on IDEAS November 6 - 10.

Broadcast schedule:
November 6: Lecture 1 - The Knowledge of Suffering (recorded in Whitehorse)
November 7: Lecture 2 - In Pursuit of Global Justice (recorded in Vancouver)
November 8: Lecture 3 - The Will to Intervene (recorded in Montreal)
November 9: Lecture 4 - The Oneness of Humankind (recorded in St. John's)
November 10: Lecture 5 - The Spirit of Human Rights (recorded in Toronto)

Payam Akhavan is a Professor of International Law at McGill University in
Montreal, Canada, a Member of the International Court of Arbitration, and a
former UN prosecutor at The Hague.

He has served with the UN in conflict zones around the world, including Bosnia,
Cambodia, Guatemala, Rwanda, and Timor Leste, and as legal counsel in landmark
cases before the International Court of Justice, the International Criminal
Court, the European Court of Human Rights, the Supreme Courts of Canada and the
United States.

He served as Chair of the Global Conference on Prevention of Genocide, and he's
a Founder of the Iran Human Rights Documentation Centre. In 2005, he was
selected by the World Economic Forum as a Young Global Leader.

Payam Akhavan was born in Tehran, Iran, and migrated to Canada with his family
in his childhood.

======================================================


Monday November 06, 2017
Lecture 1: The Knowledge of Suffering

'Struggling for justice': How Payam Akhavan lost his home in Iran and found
human rights

The first of Akhavan's lectures focuses largely on how he fled to Canada and was
inspired by the rebellion of Mona Mahmudnizhad, a young woman around his age
from the Iranian Bahai community in Tehran.

"I had a stark choice: to exercise my freedom to become a bystander, or to
commit my life to struggling for justice."

That's the difficult decision Payam Akhavan - this year's CBC Massey Lecturer -
had to make after fleeing the Iran of Ayatollah Khomeini in the 1970s for
Canada, where he had his awakening to human rights.

That awakening came when he was a teenager, and heard what had happened to Mona
Mahmudnizhad, a young woman around his age from the Iranian Bahai community in
Tehran.

Mona had been assigned in school to write an essay about religious freedom. She
was expected to praise the government, but instead used the essay to speak out
about her lack of freedom.

"After she wrote that essay, the authorities raided her home," Akhavan explains
in the first of his lectures. "They arrested her and her father. Her mother
begged them not to take her daughter, saying she is just a child. And they
produced the essay and they said the person who wrote this essay is not a
child."

Mona and her father were put in prison, where they were tortured for several
months. In June 1983, she was killed alongside nine other Iranian Bahai women.
Mona was hanged on a polo field, the same place where her father had been
executed.

Yet even in those final moments, she showed courage and rebellion.

"We know that when Mona was on the gallows that she, with the noose around her
neck, smiled at her executioner in a final act of defiance," Akhavan said. "This
just shattered my world. It completely changed the course of my life."

Akhavan went on to become a famed human rights lawyer and scholar; he is a
former UN prosecutor and has served as legal counsel before the International
Court of Justice and the Supreme Courts in Canada and the U.S.

His work with the UN put him in front of some of the worst human rights
struggles, on the ground in Rwanda, Bosnia and East Timor.

He touches on many of these human rights abuses, and what can be done to help
out, as part of his lectures, optimistically named In Search of a Better World.
This first lecture was delivered in Whitehorse.

"There can be no global outcry if we don't raise our voices," he told the crowd
there.

Key moments from Akhavan's first lecture:

"I was told that Canada is the promised land, but I pined for Iran. From the
vantage point of schoolyard politics, I was a despised minority in Canada.
I was not yet aware that I was a much more despised minority in Iran. There
was seemingly no escape from this prison of identity. Confined by its
oppressive walls, the best I could do was to retreat inside of myself and
find comfort in romanticized memories, a stubborn clinging to an
increasingly perfect past."

"The problem with the world is not a shortage of brilliant theories or
feel-good slogans. The problem is that we confuse proliferation of
progressive terminology with empathy and engagement. We say the right
things, but we fail to act on them because we want to feel virtuous without
paying a price. There can be no meaningful change if we choose to look down
at the arena of anguish from thirty thousand feet."


--------------------


Tuesday November 07, 2017
CBC Massey Lecture 2: The Pursuit of Global Justice

Bringing 'bad guys' to global justice: Payam Akhavan on prosecuting war
criminals

In his second Massey Lecture, Payam Akhavan details just how hard it is to
punish war criminals, recalling his time with the UN as a prosecutor at The
Hague and on the streets of Sarajevo, among other conflict zones.

Payam Akhavan says he went into Sarajevo with the UN hoping to "save the world"
and bring "bad guys" to justice.

But he quickly learned how hard it is to punish war criminals.

He left there a very different person, "struggling to save" his own soul. It's a
key theme in the second of his CBC Massey Lectures, recorded earlier this year
in Vancouver.

"Is it ever possible to achieve justice after genocide?" he asks in the book
which accompanies the lecture. "Or is its enormity such that no punishment is
enough?"

At least as far back as the American Civil War, people have been trying to
figure out some rules for combat. Right through the two world wars, there was
discussion on what seemed morally acceptable in international conflict. But by
1995 and the war in Bosnia, the rules seemed to have disappeared.

Akhavan, then a UN prosecutor at The Hague, worked to bring them back.

"The reality was that we had a lofty mandate to enforce humanitarian law but no
means for arresting fugitives."

Akhavan recalls seeing Bosnian Serb leaders Radovan Karadzic and Ratko Mladic in
Geneva at one of the meetings of the Yugoslav Peace Conference and feeling
angry.

"The sight of these monstrous men being treated as dignitaries was repugnant,"
he said. "It was obscene, I thought to myself, that a bicycle thief in Geneva
was more likely to be punished than a war criminal."?

Things changed in 1997, when a mission called Operation Tango tracked down two
officials both charged with genocide. Milan Kovacevic was flown to The Hague and
put on trial, while Simo Drljaca was killed in firefight with the soldiers.

"The suspected war criminals were no longer laughing at the toothless Hague
Tribunal. They understood the language of force very well."

Key moments from Akhavan's second lecture:

"Global justice, however weak and selective in practice, is no longer a
utopian fantasy. The emergence of this new conception of international
legitimacy stands in sharp contrast to the casual acceptance of atrocities
throughout much of history. For too long, the extermination and enslavement
of vanquished nations was deemed the natural right of the victor. But in
today's world, atrocities are no longer acceptable. The transformation of
ritual barbarity into an international crime cannot be taken for granted.
It was, and remains, an epic story of defending humanity in the darkness of
despair."

"On [Sarajevo's] Selimovic Boulevard, as we peered out the small window in
the back of the UN armoured vehicles, the sight of dead bodies had become
disturbingly normalized. Many had no choice but to walk through Sniper's
Alley in their daily search for food and water. There was an open stretch
of the boulevard that was exposed to sniper fire from the surrounding
rooftops and hills. Once the pedestrians reached that crossing, they would
run as fast as they could, resigned to their possible fate."


--------------------


Wednesday November 08, 2017
CBC Massey Lecture 3: The Will to Intervene

'Justice cannot bring back the dead': Payam Akhavan recalls Rwanda horrors

In his third Massey Lecture, Payam Akhavan revisits the genocide in Rwanda,
talks about the work he did there, and what can be done to prevent such abuses
from happening again.

Estimates vary but somewhere between 800,000 and one million people were killed
in Rwanda in just 100 days back in 1994.

Most were Tutsis, massacred by Hutus, who were often their neighbours. And Payam
Akhavan, human rights lawyer, McGill prof and this year's Massey Lecturer, was
stunned that there was no will to intervene.

"It was a Holocaust in the making, but not one concealed behind the walls of
concentration camps," he said. "It was unfolding in plain sight, and the world
watched on television, and did nothing."

Akhavan did something, though.

In 1995, a year after the killings, he travelled there to help set up the newly
established International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR). The tribunal
hoped to bring criminals to justice, which can be a daunting task, something
Akhavan explained in his lecture about Bosnia.

According to the ICTR, the tribunal indicted 93 individuals, 62 of whom were
sentenced.

"The problem isn't that radical evil is unstoppable. The problem is that we
usually don't really care about hatred and violence unless it affects us
directly," Akhavan explains in his third lecture.

"Rwanda taught me that there is nothing inevitable about radical evil. Radical
evil is a political construction. It's a political choice. It is predictable and
is therefore preventable."

Key dates in Rwandan genocide, aftermath:
April 6 1994, evening: Rwandan president Juvenal Habyarimana's plane is shot
down. He is killed in the crash, which was blamed on Tutsis.
April-July 1994: Between 800,000 and one million people are killed, mostly
Tutsis. Akhavan called it "a rate of mass murder far more efficient than
the Nazi concentration camps."
July 19 1994: After victories from the Tutsi-led Rwandan Patriotic Front,
the genocide ends.
1995: Opening of the ICTR in Arusha, Tanzania, with offices in Kigali,
Rwanda.
July 9 1997: First ICTR trial begins, against Jean-Paul Akayesu. Akayesu was
mayor of Taba, Rwanda, where many Tutsis were killed.
December 31 2015: Closure of the ICTR.

Key quotes in Akhavan's third lecture:

"The dehumanization of others is always a precondition for their
destruction. We cannot harm those for whom we have empathy. The killer, the
torturer, must first convince himself that his cruelty is in the name of a
greater good, a glorious act of cleansing and purification. The
demonization of others is less about the reality of the victim, and more
about the needs of the perpetrator; it is often no more than a projection
of his own fragile self-image. As Jean-Paul Sartre famously said: "If the
Jew did not exist, the anti-Semite would invent him."

"Extreme violence is impossible without hate propaganda. Such hatred though
is instrumental, not impulsive. We may feel deep-seated resentment towards
others, but the transformation of such impulses into an instrument of
systemic violence, far from being a spontaneous crime of passion, requires
careful premeditation and planning."


--------------------


Thursday November 09, 2017
CBC Massey Lecture 4: The Oneness of Humankind
Payam Akhavan stopped working in war zones. But death and destruction followed him

Payam Akhavan's fourth Massey Lecture focuses on how the world can move forward
after the collapse of the Soviet Union, the implosion of Afghanistan and the
deadly 9/11 terrorist attacks.

As a former UN worker, Payam Akhavan had seen death, grief and devastation
firsthand, on the streets of Sarajevo and in post-genocide Rwanda. But it's
something he never expected to follow him to New York.

That changed on Sept. 11, 2001.

The human rights lawyer (and this year's Massey lecturer) was living in New York
at the time with his wife and their two-year-old son. The two of them, along
with his in-laws, were supposed to be visiting the World Trade Centre (WTC) the
morning of the attacks.

And as the attacks unfolded, phone lines went down. That meant Akhavan, at work
in his office, couldn't get in touch with his family. He feared the worst.

"Now it was my own family that was missing. I couldn't just get on the UN
airlift and leave the suffering behind," as he could in Sarajevo.

However, his son was being fussy that morning and the family took a later train
into Manhattan. If they had stuck to their plan, they would have been at the WTC
when the planes struck.

"The randomness of life and death was humbling," he told the crowd during the
fourth of his lectures, delivered earlier this year in St. John's.

"The irony of my predicament was that I had left the UN to escape the toll that
war and violence had taken on my family life. I had traded bullets and bombs for
an office in a sleek skyscraper in Manhattan."

Sept. 11, the collapse of the Soviet Union, the implosion of Afghanistan - these
were all defining moments as Akhavan continued his foray into human rights.

He details each in his fourth lecture, exploring how we can move beyond hatred
and division into making a better world.

"The unification of all peoples into a world commonwealth is not only possible;
it is inevitable," Akhavan explains. "The only question is whether we will
achieve it by vision and volition, or after unimaginable calamities leave us
with no other choice."

Key quotes in Akhavan's fourth lecture:

"In the eyes of the Muslim masses, Osama [Bin Laden] was different. Hailing
from one of the richest families, he had given up a life of privilege to
wage jihad from the desolate caves of Afghanistan. For those on the Arab
street in search of purpose and power, he instilled confidence that faith
alone could bring an evil superpower to its knees."

"The purveyors of political mirages have preyed on base instincts of fear,
avarice, and hatred among the masses. They have demonized, dominated, and
destroyed others to promote the supremacy of a particular class, nation,
race, or creed."


--------------------


Friday November 10, 2017
CBC Massey Lecture 5: The Spirit of Human Rights
'Hijacking human rights': What stands in the way of a better world

In his final lecture, Payam Akhavan looks through the eyes of a suicide bomber
to chart the rise of extremism and the decline of 'basic human dignity.' He
concludes the series explaining how we can end hate and see how interconnected
we all are.

After watching world leaders, bigwig CEOs and pop stars schmooze over drinks at
the 2006 World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, Payam Akhavan wondered just
how these elites were actually "improving the state of the world."

After all, that's the motto he saw emblazoned on a banner at the forum.

Instead, in a star-studded sea of personalities, Akhavan found "a decided lack
of humility."

"The idea that was absent at Davos was how the rich and famous could help change
the same neo-liberal order that had allowed them to amass obscene fortunes to
the exclusion of the 99 per cent," Akhavan said, who is this year's Massey
lecturer.

He goes on to argue that the rich and famous are "hijacking human rights for
their own purposes."

"While self-righteous elites point accusatory fingers from thirty thousand feet,
the extremists have tapped into public rage and alienation with considerable
success."

Akhavan, a human rights lawyer and McGill professor, saw those qualities in
Ahmed Qasim al-Khateb, a young suicide bomber whom he met in an Iraqi prison.

"He spoke with unwavering confidence about his sacred mission," said Akhavan,
who was in Iraq to examine ISIS atrocities and try to find ways to bring about
justice.

"A train-wreck of shame, humiliation and trauma, Ahmed had nothing to lose. In
joining ISIS, he had suddenly found an identity, an illusion of power." But he
also revealed to Akhavan that he missed his mother and wanted to go to school.

It's just one of the examples of the collapse of "basic human dignity" that
Akhavan gives in his final lecture, recorded last month in Toronto.

And we're not immune.

Akhavan concludes the series by bringing up the plight of Canada's Indigenous
people. As an immigrant to Canada, he pictured the country as a "human rights
paradise." Discovering our troubled Indigenous history made him rethink that.

"If we want to move beyond feel-good platitudes, if we want something better
than cynical despair, we need a brutally honest conversation about the greed,
hypocrisy, corruption and arrogance that has brought us to this difficult
place," he said.

"None of us, no matter how accomplished, is on top of the world; we are all a
part of it, every single one of us."

Key quotes in Akhavan's fifth and final lecture:

"It seemed utterly foolish for people to think that somehow the unholy
trinity of the mega-rich, political opportunists, and fashionable
entertainers would do the right thing; that they would act with
selflessness to achieve meaningful change. Compassion kitsch by the one
per cent was surely not the way to build a better world."

"Just as we worship the secular sacred, just as we celebrate our inherent
dignity, we also indulge in the crass materialism and self-absorption of
our consumerist culture. The glorification of greed breeds apathy to the
suffering of others; it breeds both cultural and structural violence. It
is fundamentally incompatible with the spiritual reality that the depths
of our humanity can only be discovered through altruism. The light of our
soul is best mirrored in how we help the suffering, not in how much we
consume."

=========================================================

Format: MPEG Audio - Version 1, Layer 3
Bit rate mode: Constant
Bit rate: 128 kb/s
Sampling rate: 44.1 kHz

5 episodes of approx 1 hour each

Other Torrents