Your Facebook Friends Are Wrong About Healthcare
Language: English
Category: Ebook - Pol/Soc/Relig
Categories: Politics/Sociology
Uploader:
Uploaded At: 2017-06-05 19:46:48
Why Capitalism, If We Only Legalized It, Would Save Lives And Lower Prices
Description
Introduction
(Do Not Skip This!)
You probably want children to die.
That's about what you can expect from folks on Facebook when you express opposition to the
idea of politicizing health, and removing it from the private, voluntary sector.
You will then have to endure fact-free tirades until the end of time, about how the
dysfunctional American health care system is obviously a product of capitalism, and that we
therefore need more coercion and more politics.
These are the same people, by and large, who cling to the dubious belief that the financial
crisis of 2008 was caused by capitalism and “deregulation,” even though (1) the banking
sector is the most heavily regulated in the entire economy; (2) on the eve of the financial crisis
there were 115 state and federal agencies overseeing the financial sector; (3) virtually all of the
regulators themselves, in whom we are urged to repose our confidence, saw nothing wrong
with the housing market throughout the bubble years; and (4) there is no repealed regulation,
including the partial repeal of Glass-Steagall, that would have prevented the crisis.
The diagnosis is always: too much capitalism, too little regulation.
Meanwhile, Canada's much less heavily regulated banking system, which didn't have the
crippling unit-banking laws that American states began imposing in the nineteenth century,
avoided the bank panics that occurred here.
It's almost as if life is more complicated than the comic-book version of government good,
selfish private sector bad, that we hear among fashionable opinion.
It's been especially melodramatic in the debate over health care. We've been told that the
Affordable Care Act (ACA, or Obamacare) saves 36,000 lives per year, and that favoring its
repeal therefore amounts to signing 36,000 death warrants.
As usual with the left and its melodrama, this figure has zero basis in reality.
Oren Cass of the Manhattan Institute actually bothered to examine the numbers. His
conclusion: “The best statistical estimate of the number of lives saved each year by the ACA is
zero.”
1
It's true that some studied find that health insurance does indeed save lives. But those studies
are dealing with private insurance, or the expansion of private coverage in Massachusetts.
Obamacare, by contrast, has by and large been an expansion of Medicaid, with the share of
Americans holding private insurance actually declining. In fact, researchers find that
Medicaid patients' results are unimpressive to nonexistent when compared to people with no
1For the analysis that follows I am indebted to Oren Cass, “No, Obamacare Has Not Saved American Lives,” available at
http://www.nationalreview.com/article/445260/obamacare-no-lives-saved.
3
insurance at all.
Data available from the Centers for Disease Control shows that in 2015, for the first time in 20
years, age-adjusted death rates increased. Does that mean the ACA is killing people? Not
necessarily, of course. But it does mean it's not “saving lives.”
In fact, Cass points out, a helpful control group exists. Some states refused to expand
Medicaid under the ACA. Those states must have had worse health outcomes, right? Wrong.
The 26 states with the Medicaid expansion saw mortality rise more than 50 percent faster.
Again, reality is more complicated than a comic book.
What you'll find in this book are the testimonies of physicians and other experts who don't
believe the standard story that the American health care system is suffering from too much
capitalism, or that only government can bring costs down. The exact opposite is the truth.
Chapter 1 begins with a brief overview of my own about the history of government and
health care. The remaining chapters are transcripts from episodes of the Tom Woods Show,
my libertarian podcast, which is approaching one thousand episodes as I write this.
If you enjoy what you find in this book, you'll want to join the tens of thousands who have
made the Tom Woods Show a part of their daily routine:
http://www.tomwoods.com/episodes
Tom Woods
Harmony, FL
May 2017