Noise: The Political Economy of Music
Series: Theory and History of Literature #16
Language: English
Category: Ebook - General Non-fic
Categories: Music
Uploader: Panchoman
Uploaded At: 2017-04-17 19:15:26
1985 by the University of Minnesota-Tenth printing 2009
Description
The present history of music, Noise, is first of all to be read in the context of
a general revival of history, and of a renewed appetite for historiography, after
a period in which "historicism" has been universally denounced (Althusser) and
history and historical explanation generally stigmatized as the merely "diachronic"
(Saussure) or as sheer mythic narrative (Levi-Strauss). The richness
of contemporary historiography, however, by no means betokens a return to
simpler narrative history or chronicle. Rather, the newer work can be seen as
the renewal of a whole series of attempts, beginning in the nineteenth century,
to write something like a totalizing history of social life, from the "expressive
causality" of German Geistesgeschichte, or of Hegel himself, to Spengler or
even Auerbach-all the way to the "structural causalities" of a Foucault or of
the Annates school.
Music, however, presents very special problems in this respect: for while it
is by no means absolutely unrelated to other forms and levels of social life, it
would seem to have the strongest affinities with that most abstract of all social
realities, economics, with which it shares a peculiar ultimate object which is
number. The paradox is immediately underscored by the fact that the author of
Noise is a professional economist; meanwhile, the recurrent phenomenon of
child prodigies in music and in mathematics alike perhaps also suggests the
peculiarity of the numerical gift, which would seem to demand less practical
experience of the world and of social life than does work in other fields.
Yet, to use a well-worn Marxian formula, economics is generally considered
to be a science of the base or infrastructure, whereas music traditionally counts
among the most rarefied, abstract, and specialized of all superstructural activities.
To propose intelligible links between these two "levels" or types of cultural
and intellectual phenomena would therefore seem to demand the production
of a host of intermediary connections or "mediations" that are by no means
obvious or evident.
Max Weber, in whose time such methodological issues began to arise and
whose own work poses them with a still unequaled lucidity, told this story in
terms of a properly Western harmonic music whose very emergence constitutes
an interesting historical problem in its own right ("Why was harmonic music
developed from the almost universal polyphony of folk music only in Europe
and only in a particular period, while everywhere else the rationalization of
music took a different path-usually indeed precisely the opposite one, that of
development of intervals by divisions of distance (usually the fourth) rather than
by harmonic division [the fifth]?")! He summarized the complex determinants
of the process as follows:
Thoroughly concrete characteristics of the external and internal situation
of the Church in the West, the result of sociological influences
and religious history, allowed a rationalism which was peculiar to
Western monasticism to give rise to these musical problems which
were essentially "technical" in character. On the other hand, the invention
and rationalization of rhythmical dancing, the origin of the
musical forms which developed into the sonata, resulted from certain
modes of social life at the time of the Renaissance. Finally, the development
of the piano, one of the most important technical elements in
the development of modern music, and its spread among the bourgeoisie,
had its roots in the specifically "indoor" character of Northern
European civilization.
Contents
Foreword by Fredric Jameson vii
Chapter One Listening 3
Chapter Two Sacrificing 21
Chapter Three Representing 46
Chapter Four Repeating 87
Chapter Five Composing 133
Afterword: The Politics of Silence and Sound
by Susan McClary 149
Notes 161
Index 171
The University of Minnesota Press gratefully
acknowledges translation assistance provided for
this book by the French Ministry of Culture.
English translation, Foreword, and Afterword copyright © 1985
by the University of Minnesota
Tenth printing 2009
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system. or transmitted. in any
form or by any means. electronic. mechanical, photocopying.
recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of
the publisher.
Published by the University of Minnesota Press
III Third Avenue South, Suite 290, Minneapolis, MN 55401-2520
Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
Translation of Bruits: essai sur leconomie polilique de la
musique © 1977 by Presses Universitaires de France
Cover illustration: Carnival's Quarrel with Lenl by
Pieter Brueghel the Elder; Kunsthistorisches Museum. Vienna
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data
Attali, Jacques.
Noise.
(Theory and history of literature: v. 16)
Translation of: Bruits.
Bibliography: p.
Includes index.
I. Music and society. 2. Music-Economic aspects.
I. Title. II. Series.
ML3795.A913 1985 780'.07
ISBN 978-0-8166-1286-4
ISBN 978-0-8166-1287-1 (pbk.)
The University of Minnesota
is an equal-opportunity
educator and employer.