Amazon.com Review
With his debut novel,
Cold Caller, Jason Starr emerged on the mystery scene as heir to the bleakly cynical Jim Thompson (
The Grifters) and James M. Cain (
Double Indemnity,
The Postman Always Rings Twice). His follow-up effort,
Nothing Personal, confirms Starr's position at the cutting edge of the revival of classic American noir, tracing in sharp relief lives of extinguished opportunity and of petty troubles that accumulate, somehow, into major crimes.
Thus it is that hapless Joey DePino, saddled with an incurable gambler's optimism--but even worse gambler's luck--finds himself threatened with the deadly wrath of irate and unpaid bookies. What to do? Drift into an inept plan to kidnap Jessica Sussman, that's what. Joey's wife Maureen and Jessica's mother Leslie were childhood friends, and Joey has endured enough anemic evenings at the Sussman's Upper East Side apartment in New York to feel entitled to a little ransom retribution. Too bad for him that David Sussman, Jessica's father, is currently trying to end an affair with a psychopathic coworker. Hell hath no fury, as everybody knows, and the result is a tangled mess of motive, mistaken identity, and murder. The lives of the Sussmans and the DePinos--so different on their (respectively) gilt-edged and tattered surfaces--form parallel strands intertwining and accelerating toward a dark nadir.
As a genre, noir is an acquired taste: be warned that Starr tends to forsake character development and verisimilitude for an irony outlined in exceedingly broad strokes. You may find yourself getting heartily sick of both the Sussmans and the DePinos--but take comfort in the fact that Starr himself has an equally low opinion of his characters, and is only too ready to offer them up, in the finale, as grist for a bitingly sharp dinner-party mill. --Kelly Flynn
From Publishers Weekly
Noir devotee Starr's jet-black [...] thriller has attitude to spare. Too bad it doesn't have wit and style to match: his all-too-familiar venture into James M. Cain territory is populated by a cast of paper-thin, exceedingly unpleasant characters, all of whom quickly outstay their welcome. [...] In the hands of a master of tongue-in-cheek edge, like Elmore Leonard, or an expert practitioner of the down-and-dirty melodrama, like Donald Westlake's alter ego Richard Stark, [the premise of this book] could provide the foundation for a sharp, caustically funny sendup of marriage, adultery and obsessive behavior. Unfortunately, Starr's approach is much more run-of-the-mill. His dialogue is flat and listless, lacking the necessary staccato, noirish bite; his plotting is mundane and his observations ("Maureen's insecurity was something Leslie could always count on. No matter how bad things got in Leslie's life, Maureen was always a step lower") are uninspired to the point of banality. Although it moves along smoothly and just manages to retain the reader's interest throughout, Starr's novel proves to be a decidedly low-wattage thriller. Film rights to Spice Factory. (May)
Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
By ably balancing the intertwining lives of two married couples, Starr (Cold Caller) has written a well-crafted second novel that should help establish his presence as a force in the noir genre. The first couple are the DePinos, who lead a poor, distressed existence, especially compared with the seemingly perfect and complete life of the wealthy Sussmans. When Joey DePino falls heavily into debt to bookmakers, he drags the Sussmans, without their knowledge, into his scheme to get the money he needs. While the DePinos' problems are obvious, Joey's actions quickly expose the Sussmans' numerous, less visible troubles. Starr keeps a firm command of the story throughout, conveying the level of depravity people are capable of while providing a wonderful tale that keeps the reader laughing. This should be popular with fans of Patricia Highsmith or anyone who enjoys dark studies of the human character. A nice addition to public libraries.
-Craig L. Shufelt, Gladwin Cty. Lib., MI Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
In debt to two bookies and a loan shark, compulsive gambler Joey DePino hatches a desperate plan to kidnap the young daughter of David and Leslie Sussman, a wealthy Upper East Side couple who are friends with Joey's wife. Enlisting a brain-damaged childhood friend as his accomplice, Joey sets his ill-conceived plan into motion. Meanwhile, David Sussman has serious problems of his own. His Asian mistress refuses to accept the fact that their affair is over and begins stalking David's wife. Joey and David, worlds apart in occupation and economic status, begin to commit similar and equally heinous crimes including blackmail and murder. In the gruesomely funny denouement, the DePinos and Sussmans sit down to dinner together. Joey is oblivious to the wreckage of both families: his wife is finally pregnant, by another man, and Leslie's eating disorder is in full bulimic mode. Starr just never lets up as he twists the plot in ever more sinister directions, and his deadpan tone is a perfect match for his material. Joanne Wilkinson
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved