Description
Norway’s black metal scene is a unique post-war subculture that developed amidst the tensions of modernityand globalization as experienced by a subset of white, Norwegian youth. Thomas Hylland Eriksen (1993:11) framedNorway and Norwegian identity as “wedged between the turbulence of modernity and the inertia of tradition.” Muchof the same can be said about black metal identity, which, stylistically and ideologically, can be seen as a rejection of spiritual authority, while perpetuating traditional cultural hallmarks. Initially, black metal seemed to be a trend,another music-based youth subculture – virtually unrecognized by Norwegian society. Within the course of a few years(1991-1994), black metal made headlines as Norway, and the rest of the world, saw scores of church burnings andmany violent crimes, murder among them. All of it involved individuals in the black metal scene, many of whoidentified as Satanists, neo-Paganists, and even neo-Nazis (Moynihan & Søderlind 2003). While much of this was ashock to the peaceful welfare state, Olson (2008) writes that, “black metal emerged in Norway
because
of its wealth,peace and stability” (129, emphasis in original).In order to understand black metal’s place in Norway, we must explore the nature of Norwegian society andnational identity. Notions of imagined community are prevalent in the construction of Norwegianness, having beencreated in the mid 19
th
century (Hylland Eriksen 1993; Thompson 2012) by an urban elite romanticizing the rural andnatural of Norway’s landscape. Since anti-Christian ideology constitutes much of black metal, it is useful to considerhow Christianity functions in Norway. Although just under 90% of Norwegians are members of the state-sponsoredLutheran Church, only less than 5% are regular practitioners (Smith 2009). The status of the churches at the time justbefore the wave of arsons had vague and minimal power symbolically. The role of the church arsons reveals thecomplexity of black metal’s relationship to life in Norway. The actions of the black metal scene and the spaces fromwhich its members operated had geographical implications, mostly those concerning the reinforcement of nationalidentity: “…black metal has become appropriated into the reproduction of hegemonic forms of national identity”(Thompson 2012:31). Despite displaying aversion to the moral authority of modern Norway, the cultural barriers of the Norwegian black metal scene are distinctly Norwegian and reflect the imagined community that is Norwegianness.Thompson (2012) argues that, through the use of Norway’s romanticized and constructed identity, Norwegian black metal has reinforced a conservative notion of Norwegianness, one that is essentially tied to culture and ethnicity.Norway’s tradition of “cultural nationalism relying on the construction of a homogenized Nordic heritage” (Taylor2010:162) brings to light the problematic tendencies for factions within the black metal scene to apply this “hegemonicwhiteness” (Spracklen 2012) to an espousal of racist and anti-immigrant attitudes.