Carnage and Culture

id: 127875 not VIP Open in MaM

By Victor Davis Hanson

Language: English

Category: Ebook - History

Categories: Historical

Size: 3.4 MiB epub Files: 2

Uploader:

Uploaded At: 2013-01-15 18:27:17

Landmark Battles in the Rise of Western Power

Description

Through vivid depictions of historic battles, Victor Davis Hanson  reveals the connection between the West’s superiority on the battlefield  and its rise to world dominance.

Why have Western values  triumphed?  Why are Western ideas and practices spreading unopposed  throughout the globe?  In this sweeping and ambitious work of military  and cultural history, Victor Davis Hanson convincingly argues that it  all comes down to the Western knack for killing.

Hanson is a  superb writer with a particular gift for dropping the reader into the  midst of clashing armies.  With his trademark zest for bringing the  gritty realities of battle to life, he vividly re-creates nine important  confrontations between Western and non-Western armies, from the  stunning Greek victory at Salamis in 480 B.C. to Cortés’s conquest of  Mexico City in 1521 to the grueling urban warfare of Vietnam’s Tet  Offensive.  But Hanson goes beyond the conventions of the “guns and  trumpets” genre to reveal the cultural underpinnings that determined the  course and consequences of each engagement and in the process advances a  bold and provocative thesis about the reasons for Western global  dominance.  Replying to those who stress environmental and other  nonhuman factors in the rise of Western hegemony, Hanson shows that the  rise of the West was not a fluke of geography or “germs” but a logical  result of Western cultural dynamism as manifested in its ways of making  war.  

Each battle illustrates a crucial element in the  distinctive and powerful matrix of Western identity.  Hanson delineates  the characteristics of successful armies–including individual  initiative, superior organization and discipline, access to matchless  weapons, and tactical adaptation and flexibility.  Then he shows how  these characteristics develop and flourish as a result of such  traditional Western institutions and ideals as consensual government,  free inquiry and innovative enterprise, rationalism, and the value  placed on freedom and individualism.  These are the cultural values that  have enabled Western armies, often vastly outnumbered and far from  home, to slaughter their opponents and impose their social, economic,  and political ideals on other civilizations.

Through his detailed  reconstructions of these battles, some of which were actually lost by  Western armies, Hanson tells the story of the rise of Western global  dominance.  He thereby joins the great debate about the character and  future of the West, sparked by recent controversial works by authors  such as Samuel Huntington, Paul Johnson, and Francis Fukuyama.

 

Amazon.com Review

Many theories have been offered regarding why Western culture has  spread  so successfully across the world, with arguments ranging from  genetics to  superior technology to the creation of enlightened  economic, moral, and  political systems. In Carnage and Culture,  military historian Victor  Hanson takes all of these factors into  account in making a bold, and sure to be  controversial, argument:  Westerners are more effective killers. Focusing  specifically on  military power rather than the nature of Western civilization in   general, Hanson views war as the ultimate reflection of a society's  character:  "There is…a cultural crystallization in battle, in which the  insidious and more  subtle institutions that heretofore are murky and  undefined became stark and  unforgiving in the finality of organized  killing."

Though technological advances and superior weapons have  certainly played a role  in Western military dominance, Hanson posits  that cultural distinctions are the  most significant factors. By  bringing personal freedom, discipline, and  organization to the  battlefield, powerful "marching democracies" were more apt  to defeat  non-Western nations hampered by unstable governments, limited funding,   and intolerance of open discussion. These crucial differences often  ensured  victory even against long odds. Greek armies, for instance, who  elected their  own generals and freely debated strategy were able to  win wars even when far  outnumbered and deep within enemy territory.  Hanson further argues that granting  warriors control of their own  destinies results in the kind of glorification of  horrific hand-to-hand  combat necessary for true domination.

The nine battles Hanson  examines include the Greek naval victory against the  Persians at  Salamis in 480 B.C., Cortes's march on Mexico City in 1521, the  battle  of Midway in 1942, and the 1968 Tet Offensive in Vietnam. In the book's   fascinating final chapter, he then looks forward and ponders the  consequences of  a complete cultural victory, challenging the widespread  belief that democratic  nations do not wage war against one another:  "We may well be all Westerners in  the millennium to come, and that  could be a very dangerous thing indeed," he  writes. It seems the West  will always seek an enemy, even if it must come from  within. --Shawn Carkonen

From Publishers Weekly

"The Western way of war is so lethal precisely because it is so  amoral shackled rarely by concerns of ritual, tradition, religion, or  ethics, by anything other than military necessity." Ranging from Salamis  in 480 B.C. to the Tet offensive in Vietnam, Hanson, a California State  at Fresno classics professor, expands the scope of his The Western Way  of War: Infantry Battle in Classical Greece, offering a provocative look  at occidental aggression as illustrated by nine paradigmatic battles  between Western and non-Western armies. Hanson sheds the overly  romanticized view of battles as nationalist or ethnic honorifics and  vividly portrays the deadly killing machines Western powers evolved for  the destruction of non-Western opponents. Throughout, Hanson stresses  the technology based lethality of Western warfare, and the role of  individual initiative as opposed to the more collectivist strategies of  the Persians, Carthaginians, Arabs, Turks, Aztecs, Zulus, Japanese and  Vietnamese opponents who get a chapter apiece. The single Western defeat  chronicled in these pages, of the Romans in Cannae in 216 B.C., shows a  victorious Hannibal unable to capitalize on his win. (The idea of the  citizen/soldier, the role of civic militarism and the republican ideals  of Rome seem to be the reasons why not.) A number of Hanson's  conclusions will engender debate, such as his claim that America won in  Vietnam, but failed to recognize it, as well as the larger claim that  "free markets, free elections, and free speech" have led directly to  superior forces. The book's last few chapters are fairly driven by that  idea, which, along with precise, forceful writing, sets it apart from  the season's secondary-sourced, battle-based military histories.  (Aug.)Forecast: Hanson's direct, literate style and his evenhandedness  should appeal to the liberalist middle of the left and right alike. By  isolating the ingredients of military success via elaborate examples,  the book can potentially draw on two separate military-history  readerships: those looking for theory and those for action.

Other Torrents

Audiobook - History
Violence
Carnage and Culture: Landmark Battles in the Rise to Western Power
by Victor Davis Hanson
narrated by Bob Souer
History, Nonfiction,17 kb/s opus transcoded from m4b | embedded chapter index and cover
ogg | 0 comments
Historical
4
160.7 MiB
2025-05-01 12:28:24
42 seeders
0 leechers
83 snatches
Audiobook - History
Carnage and Culture: Landmark Battles in the Rise to Western Power
by Victor Davis Hanson
narrated by Bob Souer
History, Nonfiction, 64 kbps, 20 hours 32 minutes
m4b | 1 comment
Historical
1
1.1 GiB
2020-02-16 17:18:25
hladytokimi
26 seeders
0 leechers
130 snatches