Seize the Fire: Heroism, Duty, and the Battle of Trafalgar
Language: English
Category: Audiobook - History
Categories: Historical
Uploader: lazerbeak
Uploaded At: 2012-12-26 13:58:31
Seize the Fire is a fine examination of an historic battle and the world in which it took place.
Description
Napoleon once referred to England as a nation of shopkeepers ("LAngleterre est une natione de boutiquiers"). This was a disparaging remark meant to signify that England was not capable of success in a war against his France. The heart of Adam Nicolson's "Seize the Fire: Heroism, Duty and the Battle of Trafalgar" is the suggestion that England (Nicolson generally refers to England rather than Britain) bested the French and Spanish fleets at Trafalgar in part because they were a nation of shopkeepers not despite that fact. Nicolson makes a compelling argument that differences in the social and political conditions of the combatants played a significant role in determining the outcome of the battle before it began.
Seize the Fire consists of three interwoven story lines: the battle itself; an overview of the social structures of the combatants; and a discussion of the officer class of the British navy. The book is structured as a chronological narrative of the preparations for and the battle itself on October 21, 1805. Chapters are set up to cover specific time periods during the day. The narrative of the battle is straightforward. Nicolson provides a description of the fleets and the morale of their crews. Nicolson provides a good general overview of vessel construction and operation in the age of sail. By the time battle is joined I had sufficient background information to follow the course of the battle itself. I was not prepared for was the sheer carnage of Trafalgar decribed by Nicolson. If war is hell, 19th-century naval battles must be set at one of its lower levels.
The early chapters contain Nicolson's discourse on the social structure of the combatants. Spain is seen as a society still struggling to emerge from the middle ages. It had an ossified social structure that was part monarchical and part theocratic. There was little economic growth, a very low birth rate, and no upward social mobility of any kind. There was no middle class to speak of and the country was effective divided between an effete aristocracy and a peasant class. Its navy was similarly constructed. Although many of its naval officers were brave, and some very capable sailors, advancement was not based on merit but through a complex aristocratic hierarchy. Post-revolutionary France also suffered from a very low birth rate and a stagnant economy. More importantly, the French Navy was not immune from the revolution's dramatic restructuring of French society. At the height of the Terror the Navy was radicalized along lines later made famous by the Soviet Union. Political commissars subverted the authority of the officer class. Experienced officers fell victim to the Terror in a manner starkly similar to the decimation of the Soviet officer class in the years rior to World War II. Consequently, even after the rise of Napoleon the damage to the French navy's discipline and spirit of initiative was too great to be repaired before Trafalgar. Nicolson describes an emerging capitalist England marked by both a booming birth rate and economy and a burgeoning middle class. Upward social and economic mobility was a very real prospect to most Englishmen (at least for those who had already reached certain minimal levels of advancement) and those prospects were readily available in the Navy. Opportunity for advancement (of its officer class) in the Navy was available not just to the aristocracy but also to the English middle class, including Nelson and many of his flag officer.
Last, Nicolson provides a detailed analysis of the cultural ethos that permeated the British Navy. Concepts of duty, honor, and courage formed an integral element of each Navy, but the necessity of victory was first and foremost in the minds of the English. Courage and honor without victory was not enough. Victory was everything and duty and courage was considered obvious prerequisites.
The arguments Nicolson makes are compelling even if one does not agree with all his conclusions. Some may think that Nicolson overemphasizes the role of capital or an incipient middle class in shaping the battle and its outcome. Some may think he revels a bit too much in cultural differences between England and her enemies. I happen to think that Nicolson goes a long way towards making his case. Others may disagree but that should not detract from the underlying quality of Nicolson's writing and his analysis.
Seize the Fire is a fine examination of an historic battle and the world in which it took place.
Other Torrents
by Adam Nicolson
history, military
epub, mobi | 0 comments
Historical
1.9 MiB
rgrdgr
0
59