Vāda in Theory and Practice: Studies in Debates, Dialogues and Discussions in Indian Intellectual Discourses

id: 1245149 not VIP Open in MaM

By Radhavallabh Tripathi

Language: English

Category: Ebook - Philosophy

Categories: Philosophy, Religion/Spirituality

Size: 3.3 MiB pdf Files: 1

Uploader: Raaji

Uploaded At: 2026-05-27 09:33:05

Indian Institute of Advanced Study and DK Printworld, New Delhi, 2016., Eastern Philosophy, Indian Philosophy, Hindu Philosophy, Buddhist Philosophy, Debate, Debate Theory, Vādaśāstra, Ānvīkṣikī, Darśana

Description

पक्षयुगलोज्ज्वलो जल्पकेलीमरालो विमलमवगाहते मानसं सुमनसाम्।

  —Jalpakalpalatā

The swan of debate, with both its pakṣas (the prima facie view and its rejoinder/the two wings of the bird) takes dip in the mānasa (mind/Mānasarovara) of good-hearted persons.

 

Vāda, meaning debates, dialogues, discussions, was the quintessential of Indian spirit, enabling and promoting the growth of different philosophical and knowledge systems of India. It percolated deep into our mindset and enriched the moral, ethical, religious and sociocultural edifice of anything that was essentially Indian in nature. As continuation of Ānvikṣīkī from the bc era, vāda helped thrive Indian traditional knowledge systems. It subsists on diversity and its tradition envisages pluralism.
Most of our Sanskrit works, covering a wide gamut of knowledge systems, are structured in the techniques of debate. This reality applies not only to the philosophical writings, but to Indian medical systems (Ayurveda), Arthaśāstra of Kauṭilya and Kāmasūtra of Vātsyāyana as well. Even great epics like Rāmāyaṇa and Mahābhārata are no exceptions.
Vāda culture involved verbal duals, attacks and even violence of speech, and all major religious systems — old or modern — were parties to it. This book also elucidates how vāta was vital and critical for the growth of our socio-political fabrics. It shows how some of the major conflicts in philosophical systems were centred around karma, jñāna, choice between violence and non-violence, pravr̥tti and nivr̥tti. It also presents the manifestations of vāda on a vast canvas during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Modern spiritual and religious gurus like Ramana Maharshi, J. Krishnamurti and Vinoba Bhave were men of dialogues. Our scholars have applied the varied techniques of vāda against the philosophical and scientific systems of the West to prove them correct.    
This collector’s issue should enthrall a wide audience of philosophers, scholars and believers in Indian knowledge systems.

 

About the Author:

Prof. Radhavallabh Tripathi is known for his original contributions to literature as well as for his studies on Nāṭyaśāstra and Sāhityaśāstra. He has published 162 books, 227 research papers and critical essays. He has received 35 national and international awards and honours for his literary contributions.

 

Excerpt from the Prologue:

"This monograph is mainly the result of studies conducted by
me as a Fellow at the Indian Institute of Advanced Study,
Shimla; during the year 2014-15. My areas of study were
Sāhityaśāstra (Literary Theory) and Nāṭyaśāstra (Theory of
Drama and Theatre). But as a teacher and researcher, I have
always remained conscious of the vitality of vāda — which is
roughly translated for the purpose of this work as a category
involving theory and practice of intellectual debates, dialogues
and discussions. Traditional knowledge systems in India
thrived because of vāda. These traditional systems have been
subjected to a general negligence during the last two
centuries or have been largely misrepresented. There has
been an over-emphasis on spirituality and religion in the
recent studies on the ancient Indian knowledge systems, and
the disciplines having a focus with logic and arguments
remained sidetracked."

 

Content:

Prologue

Acknowledgements

1. The Nature of Vāda

Vāda, Saṁvāda and Vivāda
Vāda, Protests and Dissents
Reverting the Gaze
Concept of Sabhā
Appreciating a Conversation
Ethics of Debate
Violence of Speech
Sandhi: Agreement with Disagreements
Language and Stylistics
The Ego, Prides and Prejudices
Types of Debates, Dialogues and Discussions
Vāda as a Digvijaya
Vāda Internalized
Vāda in Texts
Texts on the Theory of Vāda
Manuals on Vāda
Documenting Vādas
History of Vāda
Genres


2. A Brief History of Vāda


I. Mantra-kāla (The Age of Revelation)

Upaniṣadic Debates
Debates, Dialogues and Discussions in Rāmāyaṇa
Debates in Mahābhārata
Nirukta as a Documentation of Debates


II. Tarka-kāla (The Age of Arguments)


The Continuance of Ānvīkṣikī
Buddhaʼs Dialectical Method of Discourse
Mahāvīra and the Tradition of Debate
Arthaśāstra as a Text of Debates
Other Knowledge Texts
Buddhist Councils, Debates and Split
Kuṇḍalakeśī: The Lady Debater
Milindapañho
Aśvaghoṣa: His Debates with Buddhists and Non-Buddhists
Debates within Buddhist Schools
Debates between Buddhist Logicians and Naiyāyikas
Debates within Orthodox Systems of Philosophy
Debates between Buddhists and Naiyāyikas
Vādas after Dharmakīrti
Return of Cārvāka
Debates on Philosophy of Language
Śaṅkaraʼs Conquests
Udayana


III. Vistāra-kāla (The Age of Diversification)


Challenges to Śaṅkaraʼs Advaitavāda
Vādirāja
Creating Bridge through Vāda
The Reconciliation


3. Vādaśāstra: The Theories of Debate, Dialogues and Discussions


Theory of Vāda in Mahābhārata
Vāda and Nyāyadarśana
Caraka on the Theory of Vāda
Asaṅga on the Types of Vāda
Debate on the Debate: Buddhist Critique of the Naiyāyika
Codes for Conducting the Debate


4. Vāda in Darśana: Philosophical Debates


Tussle between Action, Knowledge and Devotion
Revisionism
Debates between Idealism and Materialism
Critique of Cārvāka Philosophies
Debates on the Nature of Reality
Debates on Scriptural Authority
Debates on the Theory of Knowledge
Debates on the Theory of Causality
Debates on the Absolute and God as Creator
Debates on the Concept of Mokṣa

 

5. Vāda in Dharma: Socio-Political and Legal Debates


Debates on Polity and Governance
Vajrasūcī and the Debate on the Caste System
Debates in Dharmaśāstras
Debates on Rights of Women
Openness for Debate


6. Vāda in Literary Theory and Literature


Nāṭyaśāstra as a Saṁvāda Text
Vāda Reflected in the Conceptual Framework of Nāṭyaśāstra
Concepts and Categories of Vāda in Literary Theory
Major Debates in Literary Theory
Kāvyamīmāṁsā as a Vāda Text
Rasa Discourse: Debates and Diversities
Debates on the Theory of Alaṁkāra
Naṭāṅkuśa: A Vāda with the Cākyārs
Vādas in Kāvya Literature
Kālidāsaʼs Kāvyas as Debates
Bhavabhūtiʼs Plays as Vāda Texts
Bṛhattrayī: As a Vāda Discourse
Dhuttakkhāṇa (Dhūrtākhyāna): Debates by Rogues
Āgamaḍambaraprahasana of Jayanta Bhaṭṭa
Vāda in Kāvya and Kāvya in Vāda


7. Vāda in Modern Age


Debates on Indiaʼs Identity: Relocating Her Global Image
The Role of the Paṇḍit: Vāda Reformulated
The Shift in the Debates
Orientalism
Romantic Shifts in the Debate
Theological and Religious Debates
The Debates by Roy
The Vilification and Its Aftermath
Debates on Social Issues
Debates of Arya Samaj
Satyārthaprakāśa: A Text on Debate
Question: So, shall the ladies study Veda then?
Refutations of Satyārthaprakāśa and Rejoinders
Dayānandaʼs Debates on Public Platforms
Ramabai
The Śāstrārtha Continues
Paramārthadarśanam
Creating Hermeneutics
The Dialogue Renewed

 

Epilogue
Appendix: Selected List of Vādas Referred in This Work
Bibliography
Index

Other Torrents