Stuff, Quality, Structure: The Whole Go
Language: English
Category: Ebook - Philosophy
Categories: Philosophy
Uploader: Meryt
Uploaded At: 2025-03-26 19:34:58
Oxford University Press, Identity metaphysics
Description
This book argues for identity metaphysics. It argues, in other words, for categorial monism in metaphysics: the view that there is, so far as concrete reality is concerned, only one truly fundamental metaphysical category: stuff. The use of the word ‘stuff’ is an attempt to escape some of the problematic connotations of more traditional terms like ‘substance’. That said, the meaning of ‘stuff’ may be considered to be close to the meaning of ‘substance’ once ‘substance’ has been completely detached from any ideas of substance as something that ‘bears’ or ‘has’ properties or qualities or ‘underlies’ anything. In more detail: the book argues that in fundamental metaphysics [1] the categories of substance and quality, or object and property, which are traditionally understood to be irreducibly distinct, fuse into a single ontological category. So too [2] the notions of power, force, energy, cause, laws of nature, and natural necessity fuse into a single ontological category. Finally [3] there is a fusion of fusions [1] and [2]. For just as there is no fundamental ontological distinction between the quality being of a thing x and the power being of x, so too there is no fundamental ontological distinction between the quality being of x and its being full stop. The final part of the book argues for the view that if two things x and y are structurally identical, where this means identical under all possible true structural descriptions, then they are stuff identical.