God and Other Minds: A Study of the Rational Justification of Belief in God
Language: English
Category: Ebook - Philosophy
Categories: Philosophy
Uploader: humblebeepbeep
Uploaded At: 2025-02-15 02:17:47
1968, Ontology, Philosophy of Mind, Consciousness, Foundations for Belief, Cosmological, and Teleological Arguments
Description
God and Other Minds: A Study of the Rational Justification of Belief in God (1967) by Alvin Plantinga is a seminal work in philosophy of religion, where Plantinga examines whether belief in God can be rationally justified in a way similar to belief in other minds. Plantinga challenges the prevailing evidentialist demand that belief in God must be supported by rigorous arguments or empirical evidence to be rational. He critiques classical arguments for God’s existence—such as the ontological, cosmological, and teleological arguments—arguing that while they may not be conclusive, neither are they irrational.
He then shifts focus to the problem of other minds, drawing an analogy between belief in God and belief in other minds. Just as we accept the existence of other minds despite the absence of absolute proof (since we cannot directly experience another’s consciousness), Plantinga argues that belief in God can similarly be taken as "properly basic"—rational even without inferential proof.
Ultimately, the book lays the foundation for his later work in Reformed Epistemology, where he defends religious belief as warranted without the need for traditional evidentialist justification. This argument would profoundly influence contemporary philosophy of religion, shifting the discussion toward the proper basicality of religious belief.